Library · Samuel Hahnemann: His Life and Work

Hahnemann's Removal To Kothen, Practice, Family Life

Samuel Hahnemann: His Life and Work · Richard Haehl

For educational use by students and qualified practitioners. Not medical advice. Consult a registered homeopath.

Supplement 67

A letter of Hahnemann to Dr. Billig in Altenburg (Saxony). ("Hirschel Zeitschr. f. hom. Klinik," 1855, Vol. IV, page 198).

Leipsic, 5 February, 1821.

Most Worshipful Obr. (Obr.-Ordensbruder-Member of the Masonic lodge.)

Esteemed Friend,

From the public proceedings directed against me by the Saxon medical men, you will have learned (I am sure with grief) how bitterly my method of treatment and its author are persecuted in this country. This persecution has now reached its climax, and I should indeed be bearing a grudge to the beneficient science, and my own life, were I to remain here any longer and not seek protection in some foreign country.

Some propositions of this kind have been made to me from Prussia, but I should prefer to find the protection I need for the few remaining days I have to live (I am an old man of sixtysix) in the country of Altenburg. In a country that is so mildly governed as Altenburg is, and where, moreover, I can still meet with true Masons, I think I may be more comfortably settled, especially as twenty-four years ago I enjoyed great distinction as physician to the dear old Duke Ernst, in Gotha and Georgenthal.

I do not desire to go to the town of Altenburg itself, because dear friend, I do not want in any way to stand in your path, or in that of your colleagues by my presence.

I only wish to settle in some country or village, where the post may facilitate my connection with distinct parts, and where I may not be annoyed by the presumption of any apothecary, because, as you know, the pure practice of this art can only employ such minute weapons, such small doses of medicine, that no apothecary could supply them profitably, and owing to the mode in which he has learnt and always carried on his business, he could not help finding the whole affair ridiculous, and ridicule it to the public and the patients, therefore it would be impossible for this and other reasons to find an assistant in the apothecary for the practice of homoeopathy.

I beg of you my honoured friend, to receive me in your country, under your kind protection, and I should do all in my power to prove to you actively my gratitude and esteem. Please remember me most kindly to our worthy Obr. Hofrath Dr. Pierer.

You will oblige me greatly if you will be so good as to speak of this matter to the President of Government, von Trutschler, to whom I have also applied.

In the meantime accept a triple kiss from my esteem and love, as from your true friend and Obr.

DR. S. HAHNEMANN.

Supplement 68

DESCRIPTION OF KOTHEN.

Dr. Peschier of Geneva, who visited Hahnemann in 1832, describes Kothen as follows: (Bibliotheque Homoeopathique, Vol. I, p.378.)

The route from Leipsic to Cothen is neither very interesting nor agreeable, though it is necessary for the driver to be familiar with it; my friend the Baron von Brunnow, who had set out with his sister, lost his way in a cross road and there wandered for more than three hours before he discovered the right way. Cothen is a pretty little town; it lies in a valley through which flows a little river, that gives freshness and beauty to the surrounding country. Wide and beautifully laid out streets together with the castle of the reigning Duke, adorn the town. The castle itself is surrounded by a garden which is open to the public, and in it many rare plants are cultivated with great care.

The dowager Duchess Julie-her husband Duke Ferdinand, who had reigned in Hahnemann's time, had died in 1830-lives in a pretty house, situated in the middle of the garden which is adorned by a lake on which were swans. The house is situated near the gates of the town and is only separated from them by a broad walk and a few shrubs. The town gates and the old city wall are the relics of the once fortified town. Adjoining the castle is a Catholic church with a high portal and beautiful columns; this church had been built by the deceased Duke who was a Catholic, for the purpose of holding Catholic services.

Supplement 69

DUKE FERDINARD OF ANHALT-KOTHEN TO HAHNEMANN.

To Dr. Hahnemann in Leipsic.

I have been using your medicine all the time, and even if I do not feel that I have completely recovered, yet it seems to me, that the vertigo has subsided a little.

I have enough medicine to last until the 27th of the mouth, and therefore ask, what is to happen after this date, if you wish to send me a fresh supply or not.

Moreover, I shall be very pleased to see you here soon.

FERDINAND.

Kothen, 21 May, 1821.

The following letter is a further proof of the relationship existing between the Duke and Hahnemann, previous to his removal to Kothen.

Cothen, 29 January, 1823.

My dear Hofrath Hahnemann,

While expressing to you my thanks for your medical help this year, and for the past two years, and assuring you of my complete satisfaction, I wish you to accept the enclosed trifle as a slight recompense for your services. May Heaven preserve you in good health for many years to the benefit of suffering humanity.

FERDINAND DUKE.

HAHNEMANN'S PETITION FOR PERMISSION TO SETTLE DOWN IN KOTHEN.

Gracious Highness, (Concept in Hahnemann's own handwriting found among his literary remains.)

Your Ducal Highness, I take the liberty to humbly ask for permission to take up my residence in your country, and, what is denied me here, to practice unrestrained my healing science, and prepare the necessary remedies with my own hands, and be allowed to give them to my patients. The noble disposition of your Serene Highness which gives free play to the development and promotion of science and arts, an invaluable and so rarely found disposition in rulers, which will weave an unfading laurel in the wreath of your virtues, gives me the hope that you will graciously grant my petition for which, Your Serene Highness, I yearn in deepest submission.

E.H.D.

(Signature.)

21st March.

DOCUMENT SANCTIONING HAHNEMANN'S SETTLEMENT IN KOTHEN.

The following document, together with a number of further documentary writings, is in the private archives of the Duke of Anhalt, in Zerbst. Following Dr. Haehl's direct request to the Duke of Anhalt, all the documents concerning Hahnemann, were kindly given to him to copy, through the kind mediation of Geh. Archivrats Dr. Waschke of Zerbst.

We hereby announce to the Commissioners of the State Administration that we have graciously accorded to Dr. Hahnemann, of Leipsic, upon his humble request, permission to settle here as a practising physician, and to prepare the remedies required for his treatment, and hence the sections 15, 17, and 18 of the Medical Regulations of 1811 have no application to him. In other respects Dr. Hahnemann is subject to all the rules and regulations of State and police; and to all the regulations of our Medical Direction, and our Commissioners of State Administration will arrange all that is necessary, especially in regard to the Medical Direction.

(Signed) FERDINAND.

Cothen, April 2nd, 1821.

Dr. Arthur Lutze writes in his "Fliegenden Blatter," No.7 of April 10th, 1859:

On the first Whit holiday of 1821, Hahnemann removed to Cothen with his whole family, and by a coincidence, he left it again on the first Whit holiday, fourteen years later, with his second wife Melanie, nee d'Hervilly-Gohier, and went to Paris.

While Hahnemann lived with his family for the first few weeks in the great Inn at Cothen, he furnished for himself, the house, then No. 270, now No. 47, on the rounded corner of the Wallstrasse, which he had bought from Dr. Heinrich.

In the "Book of Oaths" of Kothen, of 1729 is entered, Actum Kothen, June 13th, 1821:

His Serene Highness the Duke, by means of a rescript of his Ducal Sovereignty, of the 4th April of this year, has graciously allowed Sam. Hahnemann, Doctor Medicinae, born in Meissen, and lately residing in Leipsic, to settle here, and he has acquired by purchase, the house of Dr. Heinrich, in the Wallstrasse, No. 270. He has to-day in the usual manner been added to the number of resident citizens, on account of the Bill of Sale, at the Ducal State Office, against payment of 9 Rl. and 10 gr. current money.

HAHNEMANN IS CALLED TO KOTHEN.

(From the State Archives of the Ducal House at Zerbst).

Very esteemed friend,

In the decree of His Serene Highness which arrived yesterday concerning Dr. Hahnemann, there have been omitted by accident, just the words on which rests the unrestricted practice of his science. Hahnemann asked for permission: "To prepare with his own hands the necessary remedies, and to be allowed to give them to his patients himself." The underlined words have been omitted in your High Degree, and it is just this permission which has been denied him in Leipsic, owing to the pressure brought to bear by the Apothecary Guild. He has been allowed to prepare his own remedies, provided he let the apothecary afterwards dispense these remedies to the patients in his own boxes and bottles. In a method of treatment where the results on the patient rest upon infinitesimally small particles of medicine, and which the apothecary might be inclined to view with disfavour on account of his own interests, it naturally depends on the physician having unconditionally a free hand. As Hahnemann himself is recognized as one of the most famous analytical and pharmaceutical chemists of Germany, and for twenty years most physicians and apothecaries have used his Apothekerlexicon as a guide for the preparation of their medicines, there can be no hesitation in granting the permission which has been given to him personally.

Yesterday afternoon Hahnemann hastened to see me with the decree that had just arrived, and said he was urged to make a decision, as the summer was coming; if a more definite statement could not be made with regard to the most important point

I told him I had done everything I could in this matter; I could not possibly beg for another decree from His Serene Highness.

In my presence and that of Freygang and my son, the tears came into the eyes of this much irritated and insulted man; he declared confusedly that he could not speak in his usual way as his temper was irritable. I must confess that the sorrow of the man touched us deeply; I am convinced that before us sat one of the greatest physicians of the century; whose discoveries will only be appreciated in their full extent, by posterity.

I therefore promised to do all that was possible and to forward his petition, so that His Serene Highness may deign to notify me by a writ from the Cabinet, as follows:

Concerning the further request of Dr. Hahnemann, which you have put before me, I will willingly grant him the assurance, that with the permission for dispensing his own remedies in my country, is to be understood, that he is authorised to give to his patients the remedies necessary for their treatment which he has prepared with his own hands, without the intervention of the apothecaries' shops.

Hahnemann joyfully declared that the promise of His Serene Highness would set him completely at rest, and therefore I must beg of you, my very esteemed friend, to put the matter before His Serene Highness.

I have put my reasons before you, why I think that it would be of very good purpose at the present moment if we could spread the news, that Dr. Hahnemann who is becoming more and more famous every day in the Prussian State, has found a place of refuge by the liberality of His Serene Highness. It will do them good in Berlin to have something to talk about; I beg of you therefore without regard to my own person, and notwithstanding the fact of my high esteem for Dr. Hahnemann's many discoveries, to proceed with the explanation before His Serene Highness, in accordance with your own opinion.

To-day the State Newspaper again defends Dr. Hahnemann. I therefore urgently beg of you for a quick reply. Excuse, my very esteemed friend, the form of this letter, due to the haste and rush of business under which it was written.

Remain assured of the unbounded devotion and faithfulness with which I remain.

Your most grateful and obedient,

A. MULLER.

Leipsic, 9 April, 1821.

(To Oberhofmeister von Sternegg).

Your Serene Highness, Gracious Lord, etc., etc.

Dr. Hahnemann went to Cothen yesterday to buy a house. The paragraph in the Nurnberg Correspondent which gives great praise to the Medical Council of Kothen in regard to their conduct towards Hahnemann, caused a great sensation on its arrival here yesterday. I regret that the copy destined for me has not yet arrived, so that I may put it before your Highness.

Etc., etc.,

I remain with profound veneration and submission, Your Serene Highness's humble servant,

ADAM MULLER.

Leipsic, 26th April, 1821.

(To the Duke Ferdinand of Anhalt-Cothen).

ADAM MULLER AS AN ADHERENT TO HOMOEOPATHY.

From: "Correspondence between Frederick Gentz and Adam Heinrich Muller" (1800-1829); published by Cotta in Stuttgart, 1857 (page 354).

22 October, 1821.

Hahnemann has recently had the triumph, in Cothen, of completely curing an inflammation of the lungs, without venesection, with homoeopathic minimum doses, which so far has been considered an impossibility. I entreat you not to be deterred by the reasoning of the world, from the resolution, to put yourself in Hahnemann's care, as long as your strength will allow you to persevere with it. The whole allopathic system, which has so far been experimenting with you is palliative, and one has to pay dearly for the consequences. Remember the mustard seed in the Gospel and how many great things nature develops from the smallest life-germs. One seed grain will grow, but a quantity of seeds thrown together will destroy each other; it is the same with quantities of drugs, with which medical science swamps the organism. One drop of extract of China or Valerian works wonders, that are annihilated by bottles and pints of these divine gifts. If Hahnemann, one of the greatest chemists of the century, had done nothing but banish the principle of cooking and mixing, and re-establishing the rights of simple medicines, after finding out from the healthy body their true effects (and not from the deceptive sick patient) and then introduced the doctrine of the minimum doses, by that alone he would be immortal. The actual medical science has got lost in the materialism of the modern age; he has found it again, has rediscovered it. Do listen to me in this one thing and I in exchange will be your faithful vessel and amanuensis, and will not attempt, write, or undertake anything in politics but what you approve of.

ADAM MULLER.

Vienna, December 17th, 1821.

You remember that Hahnemann himself advised me not to take his powders in my present condition. It has remained like that, and I may well say that since the middle of October I have felt so well, as never since May, 1818. If I reach the Spring like this without a new attack I shall gather courage for a long time; should a relapse occur, I shall return at once to Hahnemann's powders. The (relative) ease and pleasure with which I now undertake all business, is to me the best proof of an important physical recovery, etc.

GENTZ.

Friedrich von Gentz, born May, 1764, died June 9th, 1832, was one of the most famous political writers of Germany, who attacked Napoleon most violently. Later he became the tool and assistant of Metternich and his reactionary efforts.

Adam Muller, who was born June 30th, 1779, in Berlin, had studied Protestant theology and jurisprudence at Gottingen, but had gone over to the Roman Catholic Church in 1805 in Vienna; after that from 1806-9 the education in political science of Prince Bernhard of Sachsen-Weimar was entrusted to him. Together with Heinrich von Kleist he published "Phobus" (1808). After he had taken part in organising a revolt in Tyrol, the Emperor Franz drew him into his encourage and he afterwards travelled with him to Paris in April, 1818. From the following year onwards he was Austrian Consul General in Saxony residing in Leipsic. He was present also at the conferences in Vienna (1815) and in Karlsbad (summer of 1819) noted for their reactionary resolutions for the suppression of the so-called demagogue efforts," on account of alleged widespread anti-monarchic conspiracies in Germany: he was a reactionary through and through which is shown in one of his works on the necessity of a theological basis for statescraft. In reference to national and political economy he was the most determined opponent of Adam Smith with his doctrine of a free competition in economic power and of the most practical development of work by sharing. Adam Muller was successful in persuading Duke Ferdinand and his wife, who was the daughter of King Friedrich Wilhelm II of Prussia, to go over to the Catholic Church (1825). Muller died in Vienna on January 17th, 1829.

DUKE FERDINAND'S ANSWER.

To Dr. Hahnemann of Leipsic We reply to his request of the 21st of this month: that We willingly give him permission to establish himself in Our town of residence, Kothen, as a practising physician. Also in consideration of the fact that in Our country all scientific research is given free play, as an exception to the general rule, We wish to grant him the privilege of preparing with his own hands the remedies required for his treatments, and to give them to the patients under his care. Otherwise We remark that Dr. Hahnemann must submit himself to all other Laws and Police regulations of the country, and will therefore have to obey the directions of Our Medical Direction, from which, however, like all Our subjects he has the right of appeal to Us.

We conclude with the desire for the happiest results in all the treatments of Dr. Hahnemann, so that his wide-spread reputation may increase, and give Us the opportunity of giving him proofs of Our special esteem and good-will.

FERDINAND, Duke of Anhalt.

Kothen, April 2, 1821.

To Dr. Samuel Hahnemann in Leipsic.

Regarding the date at the end of this answer, "April 2" (in the text itself an error must have crept in, as naturally it must mean 21st of last month and not of this month) it is to be assumed that comparing it with the later date of the Consul General, April 9th, the dating in advance had been purposely carried out by the Government Office. The recipient of the writing was to feel as if the more propitious and liberal exposition of the Cabinet letter was issued immediately after, or perhaps before, the drafting of the curt letter of the Government, from the Duke's own decision, therefore not through Hahnemann's remonstrances, and mediation from Leipsic. The wording and contents of the documents show irrefutably that the more liberal and welcome interpretation of the patient for residence, came from the Ducal Cabinet after the petition of the Consul General.

Supplement 70

HAHNEMANN'S LECTURES AT THE UNIVERSITY OF LEIPSIC

are in the official "Catalogus Lectionum" of the University indexed as follows:

W.S. 1812-13. (Winter Session)

D. Sam. Hahnemann, bin. dieb. h. III historiam medicinae enarrabit secundum schedas suas, gratis; quat. dieb. h. III institutions artis morbos hominum sanandi duce libro: Organon of the Rational Art of Healing.

S.S. 1813. (Summer Session)

D. Sam. Hahnemann, bin. dieb. h. II, Institutiones praxeos medicae gratis tradet, sequuturus librum suum (Organon of the Rational Art of Healing); quartern. dieb. h. II historiam medicinae docebit gratis.

W.S. 1813-14.

D. Sam. Hahnemann, quat. dieb. h. II Institutiones medicinae; bin. dieb. h. ead. historian medicinae gratis tradere perget.

S.S. 1814.

D. Sam. Hahnemann, horis constituend. artem sanandi docebit, et bin. dieb. h. II historiam medicinae tradere perget.

W.S. 1814-15.

D. Sam. Hahnemann, dieb. Lun. et Mart. Institutiones medicinae, dieb. Jov. et Ven. historiam medicinae pragmaticam, utramque gratis tradere perget.

S.S. 1815.

D. Sam. Hahnemann, quat. dieb. h. II Institutiones medicinae homoeopathicae secundum Organon of the Rational Art of Healing tradet.

W.S. 1815-16.

D. Sam. Hahnemann, bin. dieb. h. II Institutiones medicinae homoeopathicae, secundum ejus Organon of the Rational Art of Healing tradet gratis.

S.S. 1816.

D. Sam. Hahnemann, bin. dieb. h. II Institutiones medicinae homoeopathicae, secundum suum Organon of the Rational Art of Healing tradet gratis.

W.S. 1816-17.

D. Sam. Hahnemann, bin. dieb. h. II Institutiones medicinae homoeopathicae, secundum suum Organon of the Rational Art of Healing tradet gratis.

S.S. 1817.

D. Sam. Hahnemann, bin. dieb. h. II Institutiones medicinae verae secundum suum Organon of the Rational Art of Healing tradet gratis.

W.S. 1817-18.

D. Sam. Hahnemann, bin. dieb. h. II Institutiones medicinae verae secundum suum Organon of the Rational Art of Healing tradet privatissime.

S.S. 1818.

do. do.

W.S. 1818-19.

do. do.

S.S. 1819.

D. Sam. Hahnemann, bin. dieb. h. II Institutiones medicinae verae secundum suum Organon of the Healing Art, edit, secund. 1819, tradet privatissime.

W.S. 1819-20.

do. do.

S.S. 1820.

D. Sam. Hahnemann, bin. dieb. h. II artem morbos sanandi secundum suum Organon of the Healing Art, (edit. secund. 1819) tradet privatissime.

W.S. 1820-21.

do. do.

Supplement 71

ACADEMICAL CERTIFICATE OF DEPARTURE FOR DR. HAHNEMANN.

We, the Chancellor, Professors, and Doctors of the University of Leipsic, record and acknowledge herewith,

That Doctor Samuel Hahnemann, Practitioner of Medicine, has resided here with his family since 1812 and throughout the time of his residence here until now, there has never been one complaint or information against him or his family in the Academic Court of Justice, he has always paid his taxes punctually and fully.

We make therefore this certificate in accordance with truth, stamping it with the seal of our University and have had it signed personally by the sworn-in Actuario.

CHRISTIAN ERNST MIRIUS,

Academiae Actuarius.

Given at Leipsic, 5 June, 1821.

SEAL.

Supplement 72

PATENT FOR HOFRATH DR. HAHNEMANN.

By the Grace of God, WE, Friedrich Ferdinand, Duke of Anhalt, Duke of Saxony, Engern and Westphalia, Earl of Askanien, Lord of Bernburg and Zerbst, etc., etc.

We record and acknowledge herewith that WE have graciously resolved to nominate Doctor Hahnemann, resident here, as our Hofrath. We nominate and confirm it herewith in the full trust that he may appreciate this nomination as a special favour from US.

This patent has been drawn up and recorded under Our seal and signed by Our own hand.

FERDINAND, Duke of Anhalt.

Given at Kothen 14th May, 1822.

SEAL.

By explicit and special order of the Duke, the State Administrative Commission had to notify Dr. Hahnemann of this immediately, and in the Newspaper of Cothen was to be published:

His Sovereign Highness has graciously deigned to nominate on the 13th inst. Dr. Hahnemann His Highness's Hofrath.

Supplement 73

PATENT OF SETTLEMENT FOR DR. MOSSDORF.

(According to the original in the Ducal private Archives at Zerbst).

(Entered June 4th, 1822).

Hofrath Dr. Hahnemann, having practiced the homoeopathic method here for a year, and no case of death or accident from this method having come to my knowledge, I having, on the contrary, learned that many patients have been relieved and cured, I am convinced that if homoeopathy is not more advantageous than allopathy, it can at all events be considered as on a par with the latter. I therefore consider it my duty as a ruler to maintain it for suffering humanity, especially for my subjects, and as not one of the physicians of the Dukedom has yet adopted the Homoeopathic system, and owing to the great age of Hofrath Dr. Hahnemann, it to be feared that his strength may not last much longer, I have resolved to allow one of his most distinguished pupils, Dr. Theodore Mossdorf, a native of Dresden, to settle in this country as a practising Homoeopathic physician, and to prepare and dispense the remedies required in his treatment.

On condition that Dr. Mossdorf is willing to render all assistance to Hofrath Dr. Hahnemann, he will not only receive a patent of naturalisation, but also be admitted as my subject.

Dr. Mossdorf will also be exempt from the usual examination, seeing that Homoeopathy is founded on quite different principles from allopathy, and hence it would be improper to subject a disciple of Homoeopathy to an allopathic examination, just as it would be useless to ascertain the suitability of a Protestant candidate by having him examined by a Catholic bishop.

In other respects it is of course understood that Dr. Mossdorf has to submit to all other State and Police laws and regulations and has to obey the orders of my Medical Directors, from which, however, like all my subjects, he can appeal to me.

The Commissioner of the State Administration has to do all that is required for carrying my resolution into effect, and to make it known to all whom it may concern.

(Signed) FERDINAND.

Kothen, 1 June, 1822.

To my State Administration Commission.

The patent of settlement and naturalisation of Dr. Mossdorf of Dresden, was already signed by the Government authority on June 11th, 1822, and on June 17th, the Medical Council, the police authorities, the Mayor, and both physicians concerned, Hahnemann and Mossdorf were notified by a copy.

Supplement 74

PUBLIC RECOGNITION OF HAHNEMANN.

In the "Korrespondent von und fur Deutschland" (No. 109 of April 19th, 1821), we read:

The inventor of the Homoeopathic system, Dr. Sam. Hahnemann, leaves Leipsic in the next few days, and will establish himself, as a practising physician in Kothen. His Serene Highness, the Duke of Anhalt-Cothen, has not only allowed him to do this, but also, graciously granted him permission to prepare with his own hands the required medicines, and dispense them himself to his patients without the intervention of the apothecaries. The Medical Council of Kothen has given by this act a praiseworthy example of real disinterestedness, and of true regard for the progress of science. It has not thought it justifiable to withhold home and shelter from this true searcher after truth, or to dispute the right of preparing and dispensing his own remedies with the most famous teacher of chemistry and pharmacy. To Dr. Hahnemann, could not well be forbidden, what he had taught, seeing that for twenty years the apothecaries of Germany have consulted his Apotheker-Lexicon in all cases of doubt. It could not be denied him, as the Hahnemann method of treatment cannot be carried on under the present conditions, without personal dispensing of the remedies by the physician. A large number of patients, whose treatment was interrupted for several months on account of the persecution against Dr. Hahnemann, which was going on in Leipsic, will now be able to follow their own inclinations unmolested and our free-thinking (!) century is spared the reproach of having suppressed one of the most remarkable discoveries for the welfare of humanity and of having purposely retarded one of the most comforting prospects to those who suffer.

In a correspondence from Cothen (March 9th) in the "Staatsund Gelehrten Zeit. des Hamb. unparth. Korrespond," 1824, No. 44, it says:

Our highly venerated Duke, who was suffering from a dangerous nerve affection, is now out of danger, thanks to the efforts of Dr. Hahnemann, so famous for his method of treatment. When the inventor of Homoeopathy found a friendly reception as well as protection in a country where the Sovereign supports every effort for the improvement of science, he scarcely foresaw, that by his art he would save the life of his illustrious patron. Nor did our Gracious Duke think of himself when he extended his protection to the noble and oppressed cause of this well-known physician for the purpose of delivering it to the impartial judgment of posterity. In perfect harmony they meet with the consciousness of a feeling of mutual gratitude.

Supplement 75

LETTER OF THE DUCHESS JULIE TO HAHNEMANN.

Cothen, 4 May, 1825.

It would be impossible, my dearest Hofrath, for me to start on such a long journey as I have before me, without expressing to you my thanks for all the proofs of sympathy which you showed me. Rest assured that my heart remembers such debts. Your treatment of myself I always consider only as interrupted. I hope that on my return you may find a more receptive soil for your remedies.

Please be so good as to give me a few words regarding the state of health of the Duke, and remember.

JULIE, Duchess of Anhalt.

Supplement 76

APPOINTMENT OF DR. MOSSDORF AS PHYSICIAN TO THE DOMESTICS OF THE DUKE.

To our High State Government, (According to the original in the Ducal private Archives of Zerbst.)

I have decided, so that the lower ranks of my domestics, who have so far received free medical and sick benefit, may be no longer kept from the benefits of homoeopathic treatment, to pay to Dr. Mossdorf, the annual sum of 60 fl. from the 1st of April next, whereas he is to bind himself to treat and provide gratuitously with medicine, all those domestics who have hitherto received free medicine, and who now wish to avail themselves of his help and the homoeopathic method of treatment. The State- College will notify Dr. Mossdorf of what is further necessary and see that the lower ranks of domestics are notified of this arrangement which has been made for their benefit.

(Signed) FERDINAND.

Kothen, 28 April, 1824.

Supplement 77

HAHNEMANN'S PETITION FOR PERMISSION OF SETTLEMENT FOR A YOUNG DOCTOR.

Your Serene Highness, Gracious Sir, (According to the original in the Ducal private Archives of Zerbst.)

A young physician of Zerbst, Dr. Ludwig Meyer tenders this petition to your Serene Ducal Highness, through me, as the enclosed testifies, that he may be permitted to settle in Lindau as a medical practitioner. I would not speak for him if I did not know him personally. He seems to me to possess good ability for becoming a useful homoeopathic physician, and is a capable physician, which is so rarely the case with the younger doctors. As I consider that my principal duty during my earthly life is to do good, and as Your Serene Highness as a rule takes under Your Gracious protection what is good, I hope that I may not make this petition in vain.

Your Serene Ducal Highness's most submissive.

SAMUEL HAHNEMANN.

Cothen, 31 August, 1829.

THE DUKE'S ANSWER.

To My Hofrath Dr. Hahnemann (sent September 4th, 1829). (According to original in the Ducal private Archives of Zerbst.)

In reply to your presentation of 31st of last month in which you recommend me to admit Dr. Ludwig Meyer of Zerbst, as homoeopathic practitioner at Lindau, I will herewith reply that Dr. Meyer has previously introduced himself personally to me and made the same request. I have, however, considered it opportune to refuse and for the following reasons: there is at present in Lindau one established physician in the person of District Surgeon Kretschmann, and I do not believe that two physicians could make a living there. Apart from that it is not sufficient for me that a man call himself a homoeopathic physician, as experience of recent date has proved, that under this heading other objects are served than the spreading of homoeopathy. Dr. Meyer is also said to be an Israelite, which fact I have also found worth considering in my reply. I am sorry to be unable to grant your wish, but I remain with good-will your well disposed.

(Signed) FERDINAND.

Cothen, 3rd September, 1829.

Supplement 78

HAHNEMANN VERSUS HIS ADVERSARIES.

In the year 1817, Hahnemann provided the 3rd part of his "Materia Medica Pura" with a preface: "A short note to my reviewers." This defence he also added, in 1825, to the introduction of the second improved edition, with the remark, that "also during the last seven years there had been public slander of the truth and its founder," by allopathic physicians as had happened before in 1817.

Hahnemann then continues:

I have read several distorted criticisms on the second part of my Materia Medica Pura, and especially on my introductory treatise entitled: Spirit of the homoeopathic doctrine.

According to the general custom of authors, I might deal with them here and expose their weak points. But I shall forbear. I do not wish to burden myself with the crime of perpetuating these follies and their originators. I would rather not expose the weaknesses of my contemporaries to a surely more enlightened posterity.

Let me make only a few general remarks.

Twisting of words and meanings, unintelligible talk that is supposed to sound wise, slander, shaking of the head on theoretical doubts, where facts proving the contrary should stand, these I consider to be tricks that are too stupid to be used against a reality such as homoeopathy represents; they remind me of squibs which mischievous boys send off to tease people-things which only hiss and crackle, and produce no striking effect, but only look stupid.

Homoeopathy cannot be destroyed by such buffooneries, their wretchedness only falls back upon the originators.

No, there is another method by which this doctrine can be overthrown if it were possible to do so; an infallible method.

This method rests only and solely upon the utterances of experience- "imitate that," is the challenge, "but imitate accurately and carefully and you will find confirmation at every step"-and (what no other medical teaching no medical system, no so-called therapy could do or has done) this doctrine insists on wanting to be judged from experience.

Here follows Hahnemann's request to his opponents, that is, that they proceed according to his own methods, by taking one individual case of sickness, and note down in a thorough manner all the symptoms singly, use the remedy prescribed for that particular case conscientiously and keep from the patient all other medicinal influences.

If then (concludes Hahnemann) after carrying out conscientiously the test, and all the other physicians who are conscientiously and carefully imitating, find the same result-if everything that homoeopathy claims does not happen-then homoeopathy is as good as overthrown; if it is not helpful, even exceptionally helpful, it is already confounded.

If the opponents will not do this, they may continue with pleasure to write criticisms and books of slander against homoeopathy. Success will be on the side of homoeopathy. This latter will permanently restore to health without difficulty far more cases of long, weary, serious suffering and illness with small amounts of medicines that are mild and have no bad taste. Do you desire just as good success, imitate in a sensible and honest way. If you do not want to, learn that jealousy gnaws in vain at the rocky foundations of truth and only eats out the marrow from the bones of him who is jealous.

FROM LETTERS OF HAHNEMANN TO DR. STAPF OF NAUMBERG AND OTHERS ON LITERARY ATTACKS BY MEDICAL MEN.

Dr. Rich, Haehl, of Stuttgart, has in his possession a large number of letters written by Hahnemann, which he received from Dr. Dudgeon, of London.

The majority of these fifty-one letters have never been published in German. Several originals, that Dr. R.E. Dudgeon published in the "Homoeopathic World" (1889) were in the possession of this homoeopathic physician who has since died. Dr. Rich. Haehl asked him at the time where these letters of Hahnemann were to be found and how he might obtain them for a little while. Dr. Dudgeon replied as follows:

My dear Dr. Haehl,

I will give the history of Hahnemann's letters, which I translated for the "Homoeopathic World," and if you then wish to see them let me know.

An old London colleague, Dr. Dunsford, who has now been dead a long time, was a very intimate friend of Dr. Stapf of Naumberg. He once visited Dr. Stapf in Germany, and the latter gave him copies of many letters, that he had himself received from Hahnemann, and also copies of letters that Hahnemann had written to other persons and which were at the time in his possession. Then Dr. Dunsford received two original letters, one written to Arnold, and other to a Baroness. I still possess these letters, with the exception of two or three copies, which my servant unfortunately mistook for waste paper and used for lighting the fire.

If you wish it I could let you have all the originals and copies by post, but please send them back to me later.

With cordial greetings,

Your DR. DUDGEON.

London, November 6, 1899.

Dr. Dudgeon sent on later, at Dr. Haehl's request, all the letters and copies; the latter, over forty in number, are still in the keeping of Dr. Haehl, who had further copies made from the originals.

The originals of these letters have met with an extraordinary fate. Fraulein Ottilie Reil of Weimer, a greatniece of the late Hofrath Dr. Stapf, wrote to Dr. Haehl on November 23rd, 1899.

My sister and I were interested to hear that you possess a number of letters written by Hahnemann to my great uncle. We would have been so pleased to increase the number, but unfortunately we do not possess a single letter. After the death of my great uncle (July 10th, 1860) Dr. Constantine Hering wished to write a life history of Stapf, and asked us to let him have, for this purpose, Hahnemann's letters and all the other necessary material in the way of writings and notes. The ship which was to convey these valuable papers to Philadelphia, was wrecked on the way, and not a single sheet of paper was ever recovered.

Here follows extracts of letters simply linked together in the order of their dates:

November 5th, 1821. Herewith receive back Dr. Stemler's gentle letter, through which the noble man can be perceived: didicisse fideliter artes emollit mores nec sinit esse feros. (To study art and science conscientiously makes one's manners more mellow-R.H.). An eager reader has spoiled with ink Stemler's abusive writing; should you have another copy to spare please send it to me sometimes. I collect with calmness such absurdities against myself.

An annotation from an unknown hand reads: "Compare Stemler's letter of Sept. 25, 21, and his article in No. 153, 154 and 182 of Anzeiger der Deutschen.'"

To this we must add an explanation:

In No. 119 and 120 of the "Allg. Anz. der Deutschen" of May 3rd and 4th, 1821, a lay person undertook to plead for Hahnemann's system:

The Author of this article, who sometimes oversteps the margin of his own science (and who is attracted by every new discovery of science), was induced to read Hahnemann's writings, as the result of the successful cure, by which Hahnemann saved, in fourteen days, a dear brother of his, who had looked in vain for help from other doctors for several years. He admits, therefore, that he wishes to testify to the truth of homoeopathy, while he begins to doubt the other system, and he believes, that he may claim the right of modest judgment in the matter, because although he is neither a physician nor a lay practitioner he has acquainted himself sufficiently with medical science in a theoretical way, to be allowed to touch the great question nosce te ipsum (learn to know thyself).

At the end the author says:

The editor of these sheets will testify that I live several days' journey away from Hahnemann, and I can assure you that I am not in any way connected with him.

The confirmation of the editor reads:

Without knowing personally the author of the above mentioned article, I know that he holds an influential position, and has a widespread field of activity as a scientist.

These hints point with great probability to Baron von Gersdorff, president of the Assizes of Weimar, who only became personally acquainted with Hahnemann in 1824 or 1825, although he had been won over to homoeopathy before that time. (See his career in Chapter 27. Vol.I.).

The article defended Hahnemann from the accusations raised against him personally, as well as against his whole system, by emphasising that the author would like to procure for the contest, for and against Hahnemann, a wider field by discussions in the "Allg. Anz." and collect several men who would take part in the contest "because science can only gain by scientific disputes, when carried on in an honest way."

Dr. Stemler, town and State physician and also practitioner of Zeulenrode, retorted in a lengthy reply which filled No. 153 and 154 of the "Allg. Anz." of 7th and 8th of June, 1821, under the quotation:

The showy lives its little hour: the true.

To after times bears rapture ever new.

GOETHE.

He means that: the Author of the first article would not attain his purpose, "because really scientific physicians who are properly trained and possess sound experience would not stoop to enter into such a controversy before a majority of the public who are unacquainted with research work which only belongs to suitable or scientific medical reviews or which can only be suitably dealt with in a lengthy treatise." Yet he, Stemler, wished to reply something. "as of late several lay people had adopted a rather insulting attitude towards physicians in general." But the object of the author who wrote the first article would be "more suitably attained if Hahnemann or his pupils would write a more comprehensible book of the homoeopathic doctrine than the Organon' or his Materia Medica Pura,' and the general meaning of the homoeopathic method of treatment were published for more general use, so that it could be in everybody's hands, as for instance Rohlwes's Veterinary book of medicine that all farmers possess."

Stemler then asserts that Hahnemann's new doctrine has-like Brown's system-"gained the approval generally of the lay people and of physicians who dislike every kind of deeper study and therefore quite naturally prefer the easier rather than the more difficult" (and shortly before that Stemler had asked for a more comprehensive manual!-R.H.). Also in other places Stemler speaks very disapprovingly of Hahnemann, his followers, and his teaching.

The cures of Hahnemann's pupils, for the most part students and those who dislike more thorough studies, and only like to ran after anything that is easy (see however above) and who as yet are not entitled to any opinion, they prove nothing.

Hahnemann's doctrine provides an open door for all shallow pates and gross empiricists, and Medical science might as well become the profession of workmen because neither anatomy nor physiology, physics or fundamental chemistry are required to understand Hahnemann's doctrine. It is not even a new teaching and lacks almost all scientific basis. (Even the editor of the "Allg. Anz." put here a mark of interrogation-R.H.).

Further:

The reason why Hahnemann's teaching has so far found few followers among the medical profession (and those few probably among the less educated) is that after testing Hahnemann's system the grey-haired physicians as well as those younger colleagues who have a certain amount of experience and scientific knowledge in the field of medicine, do not see any advantages in the same over their previous knowledge.

Generally speaking Hahnemann appears to me (Dr. Stemler) as a second Theophrastus Bombastus Paracelsus, who treated with contempt and rejected all previous knowledge, although often using it only wishing to let his personality shine by exclaiming: "Away oh! thou Hippocrates, Galen, Rhazes, Avicenna and so on. You must follow me, not I you; mine is the monarchy."

Stemler would only acknowledge that Hahnemann had discovered several good mercurial remedies, had brought to light some others previously forgotten, added some new ones to the already existing rich treasury of medicines, and established the use of others in cases where previously they had not been considered. His Similia Similibus, however, had been made use of before and signifies no new system. The assumed successful cures are mostly due to the "vis medicatrix nature" (healing powers of nature), which had come into activity at that special time, so as to effect a healing crisis, "for physicians are to be the ministers (ministri naturae) and not the masters of nature.'"

Also Stemler explained a few more differences of opinion that he had with the author of the first article.

Dr. G.W. Gross, medical practitioner and surgeon of Juterbogk (see his career in Chapter 27, Vol. I) replied powerfully and with length of detail through three numbers, No. 256, 257 and 258 on the 20th, 21st and 22nd of September, 1821, so that Stemler from that time onwards preferred to be silent.

In December, 1821, another layman came forward openly to support homoeopathy. This was C. G. Fleming, preacher of Ziegelrode in Thuringen, who had been fully restored to health by the help of Dr. Stapf of Naumberg, after having suffered for oneand-three-quarter years from an illness which no allopathic physician had been able to cure.

Let us return after this short digression, to Hahnemann's original letters.

Hahnemann wrote in a letter to Dr. Wislicenus of Eisenach:

Kothen, 25 Decr., 1823.

Caspari's article in book 6 appears to be a kind of refutation of his former odious pamphlet. If he becomes converted I shall forgive him as I did all my previous slanderers, who did not know me, but only blew in chorus with others on the horn of the Devil, the father of all slander and lies. In the meantime I rejoice with you over your reply to the pamphlet, which is sure to be well done as it come from a good heart. I have not read this pamphlet of his, as my friends with good intention would not send it to me, and therefore I do not wish to read it in any case.

I have already experienced such invective writings quite often enough. If they at least did more or less justice to science, for this constraint put upon them by having to praise the thing, they sought as a rule, indemnity by malicious disparagement and abuse of the originator, which always discloses a jealous disposition of mind which is unworthy of high scientific attainment. Instead of thanking him for his present (because by paying for one copy of these writings the contents is never paid for, perhaps the publisher is paid but never the author) they let him feel their ungrateful mind. Habeant sibi (they shall have their way-R.H.). They have rendered me good service through it by keeping me humble as I should be, and taught me at the same time the futility of the world's praise or reproof, together with the necessity of limiting myself to my own conviction.

Converts are only mongrels, amphibious creatures, the majority of which are still grovelling in the mud of the allopathic bog, and only rarely dare to lift up their heads freely to the purer air of truth.

This remark of Hahnemann in the foregoing letter is in reference to Dr. Caspari's attempt at amalgamating homoeopathy and allopathy. He afterwards became completely converted to homoeopathy and spoke publicly in its favour. In an article of December 9th, 1824, published on January 3rd, 1825,in No. 2 of the "Allg. Anz." he pointed out in detail the value of homoeopathy. A little essay bearing the title: "Some remarks on the relationship of homoeopathy to the State" closes with the words:

Considering the happy combination of such brilliant attributes is it not thoughtless and shameful, if physicians who have no knowledge of the new method of treatment, say: "We have neither time nor inclination to make ourselves familiar with homoeopathy, but declare ourselves its decided enemies," especially when they try to influence the Government to suppress it In this they will not succeed, because we no longer live in the times of Galilee, where sciences which every weakling failed to understand were denied by oath.

1 September, 1825 (to Dr. Stapf).

I do not possess Kurt Sprengler's programme. D. Balogh only gave it me to read, and did not appear to want to part with it. I will write to Halle to-morrow, and try to obtain it and then you shall have it. But the thing is not worth the trouble; the ordinary theoretical arguments which have been already refuted a hundred times are crowded together on one sheet. Besides you know well that such a programme has no readers. The promotus (the candidate for the doctor's degree-R.H.) has it pinned to his dissertation and does not look at it again; the remainder are afterwards disturbed to the other students of medicine with the dissertation, who even if they understand what it contains, have no influence on the scientific world. In six months time, and perhaps sooner, it will be put aside and not be looked at again. It is as good as non-existent, and I think that if I were to refute it, it would give it too much honour and make it more known than it is, or deserves to be. But he had-which is the most infamous part of it-from the very beginning (without knowing me personally or otherwise having come in touch with me) reviled my blameless character, on which point I have written him a latter which he cannot very well put in his looking-glass, and may hasten his end.

He naturally has not replied to that.

In any case when the adversary attacks the doctrine and its originator-who is conscious of being nobler than thousands of his fellow beings-and has burdened him with slander which wretched fellows have inverted, he is already lost in the eyes of honest minded readers. For whoever undertook this Herculean task (already in advance I predicted the most bitter persecution) and carried it out steadfastly and unshaken, simply for the benefit of humanity-for the wretched remuneration given by the publisher is no compensation for a life's sacrifice-must indeed be a thoroughly good man; the unprejudiced reader sees that and despises the evil writer of books, and does not put any more faith in him, and all his scribble makes no further impression.

Do not be too much afraid because so many big bullets are fired against us, they miss the mark and are as light as feathers, and if we are honest they cannot harm us, or the good cause; for what is good remains good. In six months time or a year all this scribble will be quite forgotten. After perusing it the homoeopath throws it impatiently aside, and pities the blind zealots; the allopaths refresh themselves in vain on it; their cause is not improved by it, and the lay people do not read it, because they cannot grasp this incomprehensible stuff; they can only understand the insults and they are no refutation.

I therefore, cannot see why one should be irritated or miserable about it. The truth cannot be branded an untruth, even if a Privy Councillor or a famous old professor writes against it. In the Annals of young Hecker, Kieser has given vent to his feelings; whether young Hecker has replied to it I do not know. This poisonous spying of the church papers makes them ridiculous by their exaggeration; but I trust that Mr. von G. ff (Gersdorff- R.H.) will give.

Heinroth's extravagances are only a publisher's speculation. Hartmann wanted to earn something through this much contested cause and has practically forced Heinroth to write against it; Hartmann admitted that to Baumgartener himself-what sort of stuff can that be I do not like to read it. I laugh at it all. In a short time no one will remember anything more about it; our cause progresses all the time and no one can keep it back. all these various writings against us are the shots in danger before the vessel has quite sunk, they reverberate in empty space.

5 September, 1825:

After some trouble I have procure the programme (Sprengels) for myself and send it to you. I would ask you to kindly copy for yourself the first ten pages where he reason, or rather does not reason, on homoeopathy, and then return the programme itself, as I should not know not procure it again.

He deals with the whole of homoeopathy in these then pages. How superficial!. (Hahnemann points this out in various places of the writing and gives some hints for the contesting reply. Then he says:) But the most amusing piece in this rag is that-jealousy of the great reputation which homoeopathy has now won has prompted him to write this programme-that is very comforting.

23 September, 1825:

The network of sophistries which is probably to be found in Heinroth's "Anti-Organon" (for thank God I do not read such rubbish) does very little damage; the readers cannot understand it and put it aside. It cannot easily be refuted-because the opponent must first make comprehensible to the reader the nonsense of the writer, before he can refute it, and this is not worth the trouble.

Wedekind's book full of rage and malice contains too many violent and exaggerated assertions; the readers see at once that it is written in a violent rage and therefore it makes no impression, except on such as have a similar type of mind, and they are of no consequence. Generally speaking we have too exaggerated an idea of the results obtained by such trashy publications. They are only firing off their last ammunition and the truth remains undisturbed and penetrates more and more into unprejudiced minds. And it is only these letter that are of an consequence to us. This truth which is so much in opposition to the old chaos, could to be stated without exciting violent reaction. They perceive the well-laid mine which is going to shatter their old edifice, and are naturally beside themselves with rage. Their snorting and futile gnashing of teeth can be heard far and near; but it is of no avail. I remain very cool with it.

Prof. Dr. Heinroth's Anti-Organon, Leipsic, 1825:

The author would grant the principle of similarity in emetics for an overloaded stomach, copious venesection in headache and palpitation, etc., when nature's help in the form of nose-bleeding has not taken place.

We can say: the great law of cure is Contraria contrariis.

However Hahnemann did justice to Heinroth and thanked him later in a special letter. (See page 146).

Baron von Wedekind, "Test of the Homoeopathic System," Darmstadt, 1825.

I am perhaps the only living writer who, as a pure materialist, opposes Hahnemann.

He attacks Hahnemann's dynamisation, and holds fast to emetics, venesections, and other depletives, etc., because this has been the practice for 3,000 years.

Here also should be added :

Dr. Fr. Gross, Court physician to the Great Duke of Baden, " On the Homoeopathic System of Treatment." Heidelberg, 1825.

He too clings to venesection, emetics, and purgatives, but thinks that the sentence contraria contrariis as well as the sentence similia Similibus has its unconditional application, each in the case which corresponds to it, here it leads to a rational cue. Homoeopathy becomes a highly appreciable and integral part of the science of treatment, and remains a treasure of glorious and original ideas.

Hahnemann's correspondence with Stapf then continues : 17 October, 1825:

And now I am coming to the most terrible thing which, as Dr. Fitzler rightly recognises, could happen to the good reputation of homoeopathy.

Kochy wrote a very polite letter to me on September 27th saying that he considered it a great honour to be able to deliver herewith his friend Dr. Ewers' message, and to send me personally, a copy of the recently published writing as a taken o his great esteem. I thanked him and enquired of him who and where Dr. Ewers really was, but he has not replied.

And now through the emendation of the true happenings by Dr. Fitzler I have been like some one...dropped from the clouds. Such a terrible tempest might descend upon innocent homoeopathy through it, if the "Archiv" (Stapf-R.H.) and generally the voice of the homoeopaths remains silent-and yet I must advise that we proceed carefully with him. We cannot unmask him to the public a Dr. Fitzler has done privately to us. We should annoy him and to ourselves the greatest harm, and also compromise very much the good Dr. F (itzler) and make trouble for him there; for an annoyed b(rother) is terrible in his vengeance.

I therefore advise, first to publish a request through the Anzeiger der Deutschen (because in that paper it will be done more quickly) and as soon as the thirteenth piece has appeared, to also ask though this paper, the publisher B.F. Voigt Ilmenau most urgently to reveal the alleged author of the preface to this useless little book, "The Magic Power of Homoeopathy," F.W. Ewers, who brings to light such highly improbable, such palpably invented tales which are utterly devoid of proof regarding the patronage of homoeopathy by Napoleon, as also by France and England. All far and near admirers of homoeopathy protest against such illusive representation, probably originating in empty air, as the value of this science of treatment does not require any artificial make up or any lies for its glorification. Voigt would have to announce within a definite limit of time the origin of these untruthful statements in the preface if he, himself, did not want to be taken for the inventor of them.

Because we cannot draw in Kochy at once, as he does not give his name on the title page, Voigt, himself, must first openly admit where he gets it from, and then we shall be able to challenge Kochy. This could be signed: "The society of homoeopathic physicians," This is my humble opinion. Otherwise I must not be mixed up in this; but it remains true that no more accursed blow could have fallen on us. We shall have to stand up to it firmly but with circumspection, so that the public may see that we are in earnest, and yet we may not use any but the right way to unmask ;the imposter, who would fain move our enemies to loud and derisive laughter.

14 November, 1825:

Do you really believe these wretched fellows do any harm to the good cause You are mistaken. Their performances are so bad and bear their own condemnation on their face. So I have written Dr. Gross to request him to prevent any homoeopath taking the trouble to refute or answer them.

Still it would not be amiss to say a few words to the public about them. I wish you would transcribe what I have written on the enclosed leaf and send it to the editor of the Anzeiger for insertion. this would I know be agreeable to the editor, who has more than a dozen such hostile articles against the good cause on his hands and does not know hot to refuse them. But at my recommendation he will destroy most of them.

I do not feel annoyed at the rubbish, for it has gone to such length that it must now come to an end. They scream themselves hoarse and lose their powers of speech, and the reading public knows how to estimate their screaming, and despises the rascals, who among their neighbours pose as angels of light, as friends of mankind, and as gentle lambs; but show by such invectives that they are raging wolves, and they must inevitably sink low in the estimation of their neighbours.

It is but natural that the thousands of such fellows who have their corns trodden on by the new doctrine, should find themselves in the greatest straits, and should utter malicious exclamations, but every rational person perceives from these cries how important the matter is in reference to which they behave so extravagantly, and that they cry out because they wish to cry down the better treatment, which they are too lazy and too proud to adopt.

The stuff they write is to evidently dictated by passion, and too full of errors and falsehoods to impose on the public and induce them to regard such bunglers as good judges of this important matter.

The truth has already extended its rays too widely, and shines too brightly to admit of being eclipsed.

Thank you for carrying our matters regarding Voigt, for where evil can be prevented it should be done bravely.

The enclosed article will have some effect. Please send it to Gotha quickly.

22 December, 1825:

Muller's refutation of Wedekind's article my probably lead to more interesting consequences. Wedekin's wretched old book was not worth all the trouble he gave himself nor I pressure was Wedekind himself, worth it.

The medicinal scribbling under the false name of Bergmann-I have also one on itch lying before me-which the noble Mr. Hartmann edits-do find out if their author is any other but Caspari

It is well that the publication against the valiant Mr. Schnaubert and Mr. Mombert, by the Society of homoeopathic physicians, was accepted at the last minute in the Anzeiger der Deutschen.

In the meantime the editor has written me a letter (He would have, to his great sorrow, to take up two more of the evil essays in his care, for the sake of showing impartiality.) in which he begs my pardon, and this does his heart much credit, but I replied to it, that such slanders left me quite indifferent and had not troubled my peace of mind for a single instant; therefore he was not to feel embarrassed for my sake, and to publish anything and everything, be it ever so mad-but I regretted to think that his paper would be very much spoiled by it-it would become so abominable though it, that the honest public would no longer like to read it. That is what he should care about and not me personally.

This made an impression on him, and he would not allow the last two essays against homoeopathy to be printed, and at the same time forbade for the future anything that did not contain new scientific ideas and proved facts-do read No.323. And thus this the area has been closed for ever against venomous rudeness. Once more a victory over the black demons!

Therefore abandon your fear, such things cannot harm the good cause at all. People who as patients are led astray are to be pitied; but for each one that turns his back on us, three others more sensible come to us in their place, and who are sufficiently clever to go by experience. I am very indifferent to it all; such things cannot in the lest upset me, for it lies in the nature of things, and must so happen the more homoeopathy advances.

Just consider ! How Jenner's vaccination against smallpox has proved itself everywhere, and yet in England so many invectives in print were issued against it, that at one time I counted twenty-you cannot find any of those now-presumably the paper on which they were printed is used in grocer's shops for wrapping cheese.

And yet how few incomes did Jenner damage with his invention, compared with what homoeopathy doses. It puts to shame many thousands, of the allopathic-guild, most of whom feel that they have forgotten too much, and are incapable of treating the new way with any success.

This makes the many thousands malicious to a high degree, they gush out poison and gall, transpose them with sophisms, misrepresentations and abuse. What harm does it do IT hurts them, not us. Truth continues its course quietly; and sensible people only think that those who use abusive language quietly; and sensible people only think that those who use abusive language are in the wrong. Let us continue on the good road with equanimity. It will repay us.

13 March, 1826 :

I now still read about other sciences, but nothing on medicine (in a previous letter Hahnemann expresses pleasure at having received a translation of Confucius - R.H.) except your "Archiv." "Hufeland's Journal" has not been near me for years, and I should not know, here in my restricted seclusion from the other physicians, where to borrow the copy that you mention, although the important phenomenon gave me much pleasure; and to think that the leader of all the writers of complicated recipes, the most incarnate ordinary pathologist, has again directed his gaze in a friendly manner on his antipode, who indeed represented him as the one who carries on the ancient nonsense of medical science in his writings, and whom he singled out to mention by name (in the sources of ordinary Materia Medica, at the head of the third volume of the Materia Medica Pura).

I would, therefore, be very much obliged to you, if you would send me a short extract of his favourable judgment, when it is convenient. i am very pleased with Gross's refutation of the Anti-Organon. Gross is growing, in my opinion, more and more staunch. But I am sorry that he has to employ so much time and so much brain on these sophistries.

19 July, 1827:

If the enclosed essay, out of the Gerais newspaper, is from the Old Doctor Jany, I am experiencing another satisfaction. He was, in the past, at the beginning of the new science, my sworn enemy, and even tired, after I had established Belladonna, against Scarlet Fever, to beat it down more than anyone else, in the" Allgem. Anz."

You surely will not think of that miserable thing, the "Biene" in the "Archiv." It is scandalous beyond all means of expression, and therefore quite harmless. "Transeat cum ceteris," (Away with it-R.H.).

Perhaps we could insert, on this occasion, in the "Archiv," what is written on page 92, and ask if in the allopathic practice, things went on as they are stated there.

6 September, 1827:

Caspari has brain; we must own that, and there is much that is good in his pathology. I wish we could give him an opportunity to approach us, and I will forgive him with all my heat what he wrote against me. It would be well if we did not let him act in such isolation, for if he became one of us he would accept friendly advice about his undertakings, and all the results of the one-sidedness, so harmful to the good cause, might be avoided. Will you see how he can possibly be introduced among us. (See his career in Chapter 27, Vol. I.)

29 November, 1827:

I believe I have heard that Voigt has sent into the world without a preface the "Lausebuchlein" (see letter 17 October, 1825). Should he then have published it afterwards with that preface of lies One ought to tell that by describing minutely the whole proceeding, to his shame, far and near, in a much read paper. He is a low scoundrel, if he has done that.

24 March, 1828:

Perhaps it is giving too much honour to such muddle-heads as Anton Fruhlig, and company, if one thinks it worthwhile to refute their nonsense, scribbled down in incomprehensible language. I do not know if it would not be better if one passed over such wretched beings in silence. It sinks, in any case, back into well-earned nothingness and is forgotten, because it is not understandable, and is of no importance. The best part is that the rascals (see page 142) own "homoeopathy has spread in a manner that cannot be explained." This confession is worth much, and we need no longer be anxious for the future of the dear child in the wide world. The greater part has already been accomplished to make a good foundation, and the valiant men, Stapf, Gross and others, have helped to bring up child well and usefully, a thing that our successors will not fail to praise.

I have now leisure to read your" Archiv" with more attention and can give you both, the praiseworthy certificate: you have earned great merit on behalf of the beneficent art.

20 February, 1829:

I thank you for kindly sending me the third book of the 7th volume, and can assure you of my appreciation. The Lesefruchte (Gleanings) of Gross are, as I have wished for a long time, small fearless fencings, victorious attacks , on misdeeds and bad shots of the allopaths; against this these proud gentleman can say nothing. That is how it must be done in order to humiliate them; they must be beaten on their own ground. But I hope it will not remain at that, but that these articles may become a permanent feature in your "Archiv"; only the attacks must become more and more serious and pitiless, I would ask Gross through you to do it. These articles would in the future, keep your "Archiv" going, as these gentlemen will have to buy it, in order to get rid of the fear that they too may have gentlemen will have to buy it, in order to get rid of the fear that they too may have been put in the pillory. These dear people have so much tow and distaff, and show such vulnerable points that the material for criticism can never be wanting.

I also appreciate the criticism by our Rummel, of Wedekind a nd Hentschel; they are often to the point, sharp and biting, which gave me great joy. Rummel and Gross are men who already may say important things with the full knowledge of their own value, which these repeaters of another's maxim could not overturn; and all the more seeing that the good cause is on their side.

5 March, 1831;

What do you say to "the homoeobiotic medicine to Theophrastus Paracelsus," by Professor Schultz, which has appeared in Berlin (And was well advertised in the " vossische Zeitung, " No. 92). According to this book I am supposed to have taken my ideas from this man's writings (incomprehensible gibberish) but not to have understood them properly, and so bungled them; and Prof. Schultz makes out that Theophrastus had grasped them much better than I.

No one had yet undertaken to attack homoeopathy from that side, and it is really the limit in criticism.

12 May, 1831:

I have asked Dr. Attomyr, by means of an urgent message through Schmit (Vienna) to chastise severely this new creation of Hufeland: "Homoeopathy," 1831, written by Reimer of Berlin (46 pages) (you did mean that trashy publication did you not )

1 March, 1831 (to Dr. Trinks):

Only in the last few days have I been able to tread your letter to Hufeland, and I have derived much pleasure from it. I must own that I consider you reply to that misconceived writing by Osann and Hufeland, very appropriate; and feel compelled to assure you to my appreciation of it. Should you take up your pen again for a similar purpose, I would like to ask you to omit all gentleness of manner, and to be severe, most severe and pitiless, so that this monstrous 10 plot consisting of men who leave all mild remonstrances unread, despising them, and are in consequence sufficiently brazen to put forth again and again things that have already been refuted ten times before, may be forced to wake up from their comfortable and proud slumber, and take up the battlebecause hitherto their deeds have only been a rushing out from the forest, without coming out into the open ground and without holding fast to their sword when attacked straight out.

All the same Hahnemann could do justice to his opponents in true forgiveness, and as a proof of it consider his letter to Dr. Heinroth ("Allg. hom. Ztg.," Vol. 47, page 152):

Very esteemed Doctor,

Dear Sir,

There is no merit on my part if I give recognition to that which is worthy of praise; the sense of justice is a necessary asset of every unspoiled mind. The truth, which you have brought to light can be proved by experience without ambiguity (even by myself) and is full of consequences for the well-being of humanity. I wish to God we could give praise to the axioms of ordinary medicine for a similar certainty, for a similar beneficience; I would truly be the first to acknowledge it in loud tones, and appreciate as well as praise its merits.

"Learn to recognise clearly what is good and to desire it with an upright and strong will, and thou shalt over the bodies and souls of men beneficiently with a power from God, previously unknown." This is a truth, the blessed results of which cannot be measure in all their greatness. Otherwise I see in your essay such an upright strong intention, that it would be receptive I see in your essay such an upright strong intention, that it would be receptive and capable, above all others, to free itself from the thousand year old fetters of medical prejudice, and-when it found a true and real doctrine which could alleviate the ills of a fragile humanity-would test it carefully, and after the inevitable conviction, following upon results, would make the great treasure its own without fear of men, or without being timid before a world of every-day people who lack will power.

It is with this conviction that I sign myself, with deepest esteem,

Yours faithfully,

DR. SAMUEL HAHNEMANN.

Leipsic, 13 November, 1827.

The striking part in this letter is the date. Hahnemann was not living in Leipsic at the time, or even visiting there. But as the better betrays, Hahnemann's style and character throughout, and as further the possessor of the letter was an immediate pupil of Hahnemann-Haubold-who was still alive at the time when it was published we cannot conceive it to be faked. We might assume instead that the recipient, as Hahnemann often did, wrote down the date the day the letter was received, when it had been omitted.

Supplement 79

HAHNEMANN'S RESIDENCE AT KTHEN.

Academy-director Albrecht of Kthen, in 1875, described Hahnemann's house in detail, as follows:

The house in which Hahnemann lived from 1821 until 1835, even the study in which he wrote his world-stirring works, was kept unaltered by the piety of his youngest daughter, Mrs. Dr. Luise Mossdorf. It is situated in the Wallstrasse (the widest and most beautiful), where it forms an oblique angle on the western side and an obtuse angle on the eastern side. On the right side of the massive oak door are three large windows with dark green shutters, on the left are only two windows.

The first floor, which is reached by a staircase with a black, rail, (This description is very obscure. The description is of the ground floor; the staircase mentioned leads to the next floor-R.H.) has windows with large panes of glass, the spacious hall with deal floor is well lighted by a large staircase window and a door from a corridor which leads into the yard. The sitting-room, on the right side, and study on the left contain valuable remembrances of the deceased. In the window of the sitting-room stand flowering plants on a high estrade and also in the niches and on the window-stills, opposite the life-size half length portrait of Hahnemann, patient in oils by Schopenhauer. ( Should be spelt Schoppe. This portrait was painted at the instigation of his friends and presented to Hahnemann in 1829, in remembrance of his fifty years Doctor's Jubilee-R.H.) On the secretaire, under a glass case, is to be seen the gilded staff of Aesculapius, which the admirers of the great man had given him on the celebration of his Doctor's Jubilee, together with the portrait bust modelled by Steinhuser. The chief wall is adorned by miniature paintings Also by Schoppe of Berlin. of various members of Hahnemann's family, to which in recent times have been added some photographs. By the window stands the old-fashioned grand piano round which Hahnemann liked to sit in the circle of his family. Behind this sitting-room is a small sleeping room, from which the garden room is reached, and opposite which the kitchen is situated. The study has been kept as it was on Hahnemann's departure for Paris. There is still the desk with the writing material, pen, etc., several mantelpiece clocks (for which he had a special liking and wound as well as agulated them every day himself); the other furniture is also still untouched. Here also is to be seen the ivory fan painted by Hahnemann's father, and presented as a wedding gift to the bride of his son. The master is here portrayed as he treats his first patient, sitting by her bedside and giving her a spoonful of medicine; the other side shows the woman, already cured in her family circle. It is a fascinating general picture of good workmanship, with a striking portrait resemblance.

Hahnemann's favourite retreat was the little garden behind the yard paved with flagstones, and closed by a gate overgrown with a bower of foliage ( -R.H.).It was well kept; gravel paths divided the small beds edged in with box-tree; at the far end was the low bower, which in summer time was hung with heavy draperies and overgrown with ivy, where the above mentioned bust by steinh user was moulded and where the musing Master liked to work during the fair time of the year, as where he spent many hours in the morning, saw patients, or took his breakfast, etc.

Dr. Arthur Lutze describes in his "Fliegende Bltter" (No. 7 of April 10th, 1859)

Hahnemann's house after having seen it himself.

The room on the left next to the entrance was used as a study and consulting room, while the room on the right, together with a back room, were used as waiting-room for patients. In the first are still to be found this furniture and remembrances, which he had received from friends and pupils. In the room on the right hangs the beautiful oil painting of Hahnemann by Schoppe, which he had received from friends and pupils. In the room on the right hangs the beautiful oil painting of Hahnemann by Schoppe, which his pupils gave him for his Doctor's Jubilee on August 10th, 1829. There is also the bust by Steinh user of Rome, which, too, was modelled at that time.

The first floor of the house was occupied, in Hahnemann's time, by the family.

Passing through a very clean yard paved with flagstones we reach the small but dainty garden, thirty steps long and twelve steps wide, at the back of which is a bower overgrown with ivy.

In this garden he (the Master) used to walk, leaning on the arm of one of his daughters, sometimes even as late as midnight on beautiful summer nights, in order to recuperate after the work and trouble of the day.

Dr. Rapou went to visit Hahnemann at then in 1832; the following extract is taken from his description. (Histoire de la doctrine Homoeopathique. Paris, 1847. Vol. 2, p. 287. :)

It is four years (1832) since my father and I journeyed thither in one of those basket-work carriages of the Prussian post, over a miserable road, broken and muddy, to the modest home of Hahnemann. In this peaceful little country town, the reformer had found the ardently desired rest, which had been taken from him after his great discovery. There he lived entirely devoted to his art. He carried on a very extended correspondence with his partisans, answered their objections, aroused those among them who were indifferent, admonished his pupils, and punished with reprobation those who transgressed his precepts.

Supplement 80

HAHNEMANN IN THE FAMILY CIRCLE.

Seminardirector Albrecht of then, writes in his book, "Dr. Samuel Hahnemann's Life and Work" :

Hahnemann felt happiest among his family, and showed here better than anywhere else his amiable, happy and cheerful disposition. He jested with his children during the time that he could give to them, sang short lullabys for them, wrote little poems in the most affable and fatherly way, after first taking care to instruct them about the most varied things and to explain what was of importance, and encouraged them by examples to do their duty, to be virtuous an steadfast. For these examples he referred them mostly to their mother-to her whose active life was entirely dedicated to her wifely and motherly duties. Frequently he read to his family exceptional passages from the works that he himself was reading, and drew their attention to the works of his well-stocked library, which dealt exceptionally well with the same or similar subjects. He and his wife were sworn enemies of novels, and would only occupy themselves with reality.

Supplement 81

HAHNEMANN'S WORKING DAY.

Dr. Franz Hartmann wrote ("Allg. hom. Ztg.," 1844, Vol. 26, Page 184):

His consulting hours were from 9 to 12 in the morning, and from 2 to 4 in the afternoon. The admission into his house was unusual. During the time in which I was in touch with him, he lived in two houses consecutively, where near the halldoor was to be found a small trap-window, in which appeared, every time the bell rang, a girl's head, which looked to like the guardian of a watch-tower, in order to inspect the new arrival; this office was performed by one of his two daughters, who took it on alternate weeks. On entering his room one usually found already a large number of patients, to whom in turn he gave an equal amount of attention. A square table of medium size, near the window, was provided with writing material. It was at this table that he dealt with his patients; he examined them carefully and wrote down even small and apparently insignificant details of his patient in an oblong quarto-size book, which he closed each time when he went into another room to fetch some necessary medicine. If is memory wan not quite accurate or if he had some slight doubt concerning the choice of medicine, before preparing it he went to a large square table which stood in the middle of the room on which were placed two large thick folio-volumes which he consulted; in these had been arranged in alphabetical order, all the symptoms proved by himself and his pupils.

(A) brilliant piece of work-the arranging of symptoms in alphabetical order, carried out as a rule by one of his daughters, and his assistant.) When he handed over the medicine to the patient, he did not withdraw the hand, which was quite as read to give as to receive, until the previously stipulated fee was placed in it, he then cautiously withdrew the same and dropped the mammon into his right trouser pocket to join the amount already present. When the clock struck twelve and four, no more patients were admitted, because punctually to the minute he was summoned to his meal, and nothing could easily keep him back; but if in the eagerness of conversation, as I once or twice witnessed myself, he had disregarded the first or even the second call, a third one would follow only the more quickly, and then he would smilingly remark: "This time I shall get a gloomy look!"

Albrecht gives the following accurate order of the day:

Hahnemann's day was strictly regulated. The great scholar rose in the summer at 6, and in the winter 7 in the morning, drank a few cups of cow's milk (warm) lit a pipe, and went for a walk in his little garden. After this he either interviewed his patients, or wrote letters to his distant friends. According to the time of the year he ate a little fruit at 10 o'clock. At 12 o'clock he had his dinner, and generally partook of some strong beef or mutton both, some very tender roast beef, mutton or game of any kind, roasts of larks, pigeons, and others. He liked veal and pork least; stewed fruit had to be very sweet to please him. With the exception of green beans, cauliflower, and spinach, he would take no vegetables; he preferred cake to bread. At meals he would drink a little good wine if he had guests; has daily drink was sweetened pale ale. After dinner he slept for one hour on the couch, then attended again to his patients until 7 o'clock, which was his hour for supper; in the winter he had warm milk; in the summer pale ale Kalteshale. After supper he went, winter and summer, for a walk in the garden. His companion in hi walks was, for a time, a small pet dog, who also remained close to him at meals. After spending an hour in the sitting room with his family, he went into his study, where he wrote at his book or did other work until 11, 12, or 1 o'clock.

Supplement 82

THE QUESTION OF FEES.

Dr. Franz Hartmann wrote ("Allg. hom. Ztg.," 1844, Vol. 26, p. 185):-

The fee for six numbered powders, only one of which contained medicine, and which were ordered to be taken three or two a day, and was charged at the lowest 16 gute Gr. (Is. 6d.), to wealthier patients I Thlr. and 8 g.Gr. (3s.), up to 2 Thlr. (5s.), otherwise he asked for a payment in advance of a certain sum of 10-12 Loud d'or, which he demanded again ad libitum, after a certain length of time. It was this latter mode of proceeding which brought him the bad reputation of being insatiable and avaricious, etc., and not without reason. Once I was forced, as I was his assistant for a time, to witness a scene of that kind in his own room, when a patient from outside the town, who was suffering from Lues secundaria cum hydrargyrosi litt. had asked for his help, and of whom he demanded 10-12 Louis d'or at his second visit. The patient would not pay but promised to pay 20 Louis d'or at the completion of the cure. Hahnemann closed his journal a little excitedly, and now asked definitely for 12 Louis d'or, before he moved his hand again, for-he meant- "with such a patient, one has to be keen about one's money." This behaviour provoked me very much at the time, but I could readily forgive him, when he afterwards quietly assured me that the people had forced him to adopt this seemingly hardhearted method, by their ingratitude and deceit, seeing that it was impossible for him to run after patients who lived far away.

We must, however, give him recognition and praise for treating every year, twelve poor patients gratuitously, who came to him at the same consulting hours, and shared equal rights with their more wealthy fellow-brings, for they took their turn in rotation, and no one, however, wealthy, could boast of having been given the precedence.

HAHNEMANN'S LETTERS ON TITLE AND FEES.

To Dr. Rummel, Hahnemann wrote:

then, 19 May, 1831.

Of course a title such as that of "Medicinalrath" has the advantage of procuring a physician better fees, especially for the homeopath whom the enemy of his science seeks to humiliate; but even if it were not so, it is advisable for the homoeopathic physician to set a very much higher value on his so infinitely superior science of healing, so as to procure for himself better fees, or at least to put chronic patient on a settled monthly fee (preferably paid in advance), and to make the poorer patients pay a small sum each time, if it were only a few groschen-accipe dum dolet. (Take while it hurts-R.H.). Only in this way is it possible for the physician to avoid loss, and keep up his courage by seeing some actual money for his trouble. Even such small amounts if regularly and correctly pain up each time will mount up to a sum, and the patient who pays every time hardly notices it in his purse, because he discharges his duty gradually, and when he was recovered, or else has left off coming before treatment is completed, he has no claim on us or we on him; he separates from us if not grateful and satisfied, also without indignation. What he has given gradually has passed out of his mind and the physician has received his due, in this way it passes from the patient's purse into that of the doctor without causing displeasure. Otherwise how much annoyance is created for the physician, if he presents the bill when the patients is gradually improving, and has completely forgotten the great amount of trouble the doctor has taken, ut fieri solet (as usually happens-R.H.). Since I have been practising the beneficent method of treatment, I have never made a claim of small amounts at the time of consultation, and the system of monthly preremuneration of the wealthy classes, has been introduced, and the patients have got accustomed to it, then every one brings his money unreminded with him, or physician conducts his establishment properly, and is a helpful homoeopath, he can make a good income and also save a little.

Rummel replied to Hahnemann:

Merseburg, 15.6.31.

With people who come to me, and with patients who are living some distance away I have introduced something similar, and it works well. But with the many patients which I have to visit in my ordinary practice, this arrangement cannot be made. Yet I have, with several families, a fixed honorarium of 4, 6, and 8, and of 20 Friedrichs d'or with one patient. I am financially not in a bad position. If my outside practice increases still more, I hope to put your suggestion more and more into effect.

To Dr. Ehrhardt of Merseburg, Hahnemann wrote on August 24th, 1829:

You are far too timid, and let your patients impose upon you far too much-like the allopaths who are glad to keep a patients as a client. It should not be so; for if you are perfectly conversant with your art, you must command absolutelyand not allow you patient to make conditions. He must submit to you, not you to him. To this, end, and in order that you may be perfectly free, you must curtail (in the beginning) your requirements, so that you may not suffer want, even though but few patients need you.

These few you will be able to treat better, and cure with greater certainly, if you. These few you will be able to treat better, and cure with greater certainly, if you have taken the necessary time to advise them, and also have time for study; because we homoeopaths cannot penetrate too deeply into our art. But when we are masters, then we may and can assert ourselves, and in order to save our valuable time, and not lower our dignity we must not go visiting chronic patients, who can well come to our house, even if it were a prince. We must only visit acute bedridden patients. Those who can go about, if they will not come to your house for advice, can stay away. All this running after them, in the manner of allopaths, degrades you. You have come to see your patient, the housemaid will not admit you; the gentleman has gone to the theatre, or for a drive, etc. Fie! Then you have to go on to a second, a third, just like an allopath or a beggar. Fie!

When a patient comes to your house, you must make him pay each time, for your trouble, from poor people it may be only 6 to 8 Groschen, from the rich it might be Thalers. If this is so arranged and they do not know any different, then your patient will always have his money with him, and if he should not want to come again, he can stay away. If he has not brought the money with him, make another appointment in an hour or two, so that he may go and get it, and bring you the remuneration for your trouble.

Money gives courage, even though it be not a large sum; if I have what is due to me in my purse, then I feel that I am not working for nothing, that I am not dependent on every one's favour, and fearful lest I should not be paid.

What payment have you received from Mr. the Privy Councillor I suggest that the greater part of your fee is on credit; and later on when you remind him of payment you will get a wry face, reproaches, and then very little or nothing. Under such circumstances it is impossible to remain cheerful. After the treatment, he will have forgotten how much trouble you have had with him. The world is ungrateful. Rich patients should pay at each consultation, or once a month. Otherwise they may go where they like. If you do not arrange matters in this fashion you will be worse off than the most miserable wretch.

I said that you were timid. Running about paying visits takes away one's courage and makes one timid.

All my patients of rank affected with chronic diseases, must have read the "Organon" and Boenninghausen's "Homoeopathy," otherwise I will not undertake their treatment.

Hahnemann also wrote to Dr. Schrter of Lemberg (N. "Archiv," Vol. III, 1846):

then, 28th February, 1829.

You should have made yourself more distant with your patients and generally adopted a more haughty attitude, seeing that you were not without financial support from home; more often than not you should send away patients, or leave them at once if they do not show sufficient confidence, or sufficient respect for you and your art. You must never allow them to dismiss you, but every time that you are not obeyed, and they are no longer courteous, you must dismiss them first "you are not doing as I told you, do so and so, just what I did not wish-get whom you like-I do not want you," and so one after the other, even if he uses words with a double meaning against homoeopathy, or does anything else unseemly, dismiss him straight away. This would have robbed you of some patients in the beginning, that were not worth troubling about, but in time if you kept to his commanding attitude, you would have been respected, you would have been sought after, and patients would not have done anything unseemly towards you. Sooner be without patients, and spend your time in study and such light things; rather remain in proud isolation than be on such terms with patients. The latter ought to thank God, that you took them up and considered them worthy to be treated with the glorious doctrine, and even then they would still have to listen to your reproaches, for the way in which they had allowed allopaths to bungle them, so that you hardly thought it possible to make good what had been so spoiled.

Then those of your patients who will not obey, send away without further explanation, although you may only retain one or two, or even in such a position not a single patient. They would then gradually return with more decency, submissiveness, and modesty and more inclined to pay well. Surely you let chronic patients who can walk, come to your house Who would lower himself so much as to go and visit Mr. Patient who in the meantime had gone out, and had let you come in van! Chronic patients, even those of high rank must come to you, and those who will not come must stay away. You must cultivate a higher opinion of yourself. Sooner starve (which you need not to), than lower your dignity and that of your art!

With regard to the question of fees C. E. Wahrhold, protests in his "Popular papers on homoeopathic treatment" (1837, page 64) against an attack in No. 126 of the "Eremite."

He writes.

In closing I cannot refrain from expressing my disapproval of the way in which the honourable Dr. Hahnemann has frequently been brought into discredit, and medical treatment. Ten Loud d'or for one consultation my seem a very high fee to the author of that unseemly article; but can it be interpreted in a suspicious or evil manner, if a man who has given up his whole life to the development and perfecting of this important cause, asks for a somewhat heavy compensation for the trouble and interruptions caused to his hours of rest, considering his advanced age And then, would it be seemly if in Paris, a Marshal, a Peer, or other very wealthy person should drive up to consult Dr. Hahnemann and pay him one france Do not allopaths of very high repute, although they have not discovered a new system, often charge very high fees Dr. Hahnemann has already made many sacrifices to advance homoeopathy, and given from his own private means considerable subscriptions, where the financial resources were insufficient, for the gratuitous treatment of the poor.

What is in this library

These titles sit beside the repertory: Allen’s Keynotes, Anshutz on the twelve tissue remedies, Boericke’s materia medica, Clarke’s Dictionary, Hering, Jones, Kent’s lectures, Nash, and Boger’s Synoptic Key. Philosophy includes Hahnemann’s Organon (5th and 6th), Kent, Close, Burnett, Haehl, Gibson Miller, Royal, J. H. Allen, and Anshutz. Clinical, therapeutics, regional works, and short remedy pictures follow the same shelf.

Chapter text is on this shelf for study: open a title, then a heading. When a medicine appears in more than one materia medica, switch authors on the chapter to compare how each describes it. For educational use by students and qualified practitioners. Not medical advice.

Back to Tools or the repertory.