Library · Fifty Reasons for Being a Homoeopath

Reason The Forty-Fourth

Fifty Reasons for Being a Homoeopath · J. C. Burnett

For educational use by students and qualified practitioners. Not medical advice. Consult a registered homeopath.

I have before pointed out to you that I love the grand independence conferred upon me by Homoeopathy: when I have a difficult case I do not want to side softly away from responsibility by the support of a consultative old foggy whose brains have long since gone to sleep and whose raison d'etre is only medico-social. I want to cure my patient and were it only for the mental satisfaction. Now guided by Homoeopathy and a wee bit of reasoning power, I can generally do this.

Read the following case of -

TRAUMATIC SWELLING OF RIGHT BREAST CURED BY BELLIS ALONE

I adduce the following case of swelling in a young lady's breast rather to exemplify in a neat way the curative range of the DAISY in the treatment of tumours.

No experienced practitioner will deny the important part of played by bruises blows and falls in the genesis of tumours an cancer; and hence our anti-traumatics ought to figure much more largely in our therapeutics of growths from blows. Before giving my case I will quote a very instructive note on this very question that appeared as leader in the first volume of the Homoeopathic Recorder (Philadelphia,) No. 4, July 1886.

MALIGNANT GROWTHS

"In the preceding number of The Recorder there appeared three items concerning malignant growths, which deserve more than passing notice. One is the history of the development of malignant formation as the result of the frequent mechanical irritation of a simple mole on the frequent mechanical irritation of mole on the face, another recounted the cure of an extensive sarcomatous growth by an intercurrent attack of erysipelas, and the third contained the analysis of a series of cases of carcinoma in all of which there was antecedent injury by mechanical or chemical means; in the latter selection the writer asks in all seriousness: Is cancer, whatever its form ever primary - i.e does it ever originate without previous injury

A negative reply to this inquiry is of the highest importance to those who believe in the curative effects of drugs. It deprives the disease action of part of the mysterious fateful quality so constantly associated in our minds with these affections, and which terrorizes to some degree the powers of the medical attendant. For we hold that the great majority of physicians, on discovering the existence of suspicious growth, are strongly impelled to advise the use of the knife as the only sure treatment not withstanding that in cases of undoubted malignancy the value of surgical interference is greatly lessened by the relatively poor results as measured by the added years given to the patient.

Moreover if the occurrence of an infectious inflammation of the skin has destroyed malignant disease process in that issue, there is a fairly good basis for the view, reasoning by analogy, that a drug-disease-i.e. a disease produced by the action of a medicine can if affecting a part involved in the malignant process cause similarly efficacious results.

In an admirable Report * "Phila. Med. Times," xvi., 484.* on the Progress of Pathology by J.H. Muser, M.D., Mr. Sutton, F.R.C.S., is given as authority for the following view: "irritation local or otherwise, affecting the tissue, may cause abnormal epithelial growths, which rising above the general level, may produce a wart. On the other hand the epithelial growths may dip into the sub-epithelial tissues, and on account of lack of formative development either and on account of lack of formative development either from decline of vigour or general constitutional debility, the new tissue never develops functional debility the new tissue never develops functionally runs riot, and originates tissues of low vitality carcinomata. The conditions favourable to the development of carcinomata debility, etc. - are absent in the young hence in the young we have warts; in the old, cancers."

What then, is the bearing of these facts upon the treatment of probably malignant tumours passing by the cures of warts by internal medicine alone, which almost every homoeopathic practitioner has observed over and over again we need only call attention to the cures by the same method of tumours of the female breast an organ notoriously disposed to malignant neoplasms here the action of Conium cannot be denied and what is true of this remedy may be true of many others.

A thorough study of the symptoms of each individual case, with the view of finding the exact simillimum, the exhibition of the latter in different attenuations, if necessary changing the remedy only when a change of symptoms demands it, and extreme extreme watchfulness for involvement of the neighboring glandular structures, make up, it appears to us, the duty of the physician. Whether he would be justified in holding out any hope of cure by internals medication after evidences of systemic infection exist, must be decided by his own experience; but, as there are always cases in which operation is inadmissible, or in which it will not be allowed, opportunities will not be wanting to continue treatment with the properly chosen remedy.

If statistics of our treatment can be collated and analysed, the results will, we feel sure, give encouragement to physicians and sufferers as well, and demonstrate anew, and in a strikingly brilliant manner, the value of our law of cure.

We earnestly hope, then, that those of us who hold hospital or dispensary appointments will endeavour to employ the method of internal medication in cases of malignant growths whenever it is fairly admissible to do so, and that records of cases containing diagnosis checked off as to their accuracy by every method known to medical science, together with the symptoms in full and the treatment used, may soon appear in our journals. Thus will be laid the foundation for a new and lasting monument to Homoeopathy."

Without going so far as the author of this article, I must certainly say I attribute some of my success in the treatment of cancers and other tumours by medicines to a due recognition of the traumatic fact, not in diagnostics merely, but also in therapeutics.

Miss L.C., aged thirteen years, came under my observation at then end of July, 1879. About eight weeks previously a miserable lad in the street hit her on the right breast with considerable violence; from that time on, this breast became swollen and very painful, until at length she was quite unable to lie on her right side. Patient's mother was poitrinaire, as was also her brother, and my experience teaches me that the members of poitrinaire families are particularly liable to suffer from blows.

At first no notice was taken of the young lady's complaints, but week after week went by, and she persisted in referring to the pain in her breast. Whether any domestic means had been employed I do not now remember, but eventually I was sent for, as vague notions of tumour and cancer rendered the parents uneasy. On comparing the breasts, the right one was found to be by much the larger, being swollen and very tender.

I thought this a very proper case for testing the antitraumatic virtue of the old English bruisewort, and hence prescribed thus:

Rx. Tc. Bellis perennis 3x. 3ij.

S.-Three drops to be taken in water four times a day. The result was a very rapid disappearance of pain and swelling, and in a fortnight patient could lie again on the right side. And a few days later an examination showed that the swelling had entirely disappeared.

Nothing whatever was applied to the part, no change was made in diet, mode of life, or place of abode, and as the thing had already existed for eight weeks, the positively curative effect of the Bellis can hardly be denied, which is the one point this case is meant to exemplify and to teach, and that because it is so very difficult to demonstrate positively the effect of any one remedy when the tumefaction has become a genuine neoplasia, or hyperplasia. *In this case there was, of course, no hyperplasia.* Too many of my cases prove this.

What is in this library

These titles sit beside the repertory: Allen’s Keynotes, Anshutz on the twelve tissue remedies, Boericke’s materia medica, Clarke’s Dictionary, Hering, Jones, Kent’s lectures, Nash, and Boger’s Synoptic Key. Philosophy includes Hahnemann’s Organon (5th and 6th), Kent, Close, Burnett, Haehl, Gibson Miller, Royal, J. H. Allen, and Anshutz. Clinical, therapeutics, regional works, and short remedy pictures follow the same shelf.

Chapter text is on this shelf for study: open a title, then a heading. When a medicine appears in more than one materia medica, switch authors on the chapter to compare how each describes it. For educational use by students and qualified practitioners. Not medical advice.

Back to Tools or the repertory.