Library · Samuel Hahnemann: His Life and Work

Hahnemann At Leipsic University

Samuel Hahnemann: His Life and Work · Richard Haehl

For educational use by students and qualified practitioners. Not medical advice. Consult a registered homeopath.

Supplement 54

HAHNEMANN HAS TO LEAVE TORGAU.

Hahnemann wrote to von Villers ("Leipz.Pop.Zeitschr. f. Hom.," 1880. 11 year, page 47):

Torgau, January 30th, 1811.

Another few words from me. I am living (now nearly fifty-six years old) surrounded by my family which is very dear to me--a wife of exceptional kindness, and seven happy, almost grown-up daughters, who are well educated, obedient and innocent, they take every care of me, and brighten my life (also with music). I am nearly always able to heal quickly and prematurely any patients entrusted to my care, and in that way make many people happy, through the Grace of Him Who made the remedies and put them in my hands. Am I not to be envied But, see, they are making all preparations, to transmute Torgau into a big and terrible fortress, in which my family is not likely to live in peace. I have to sell my dear and comfortable freehold house and move hence--undecided--where You see, dear friend,in this way the all-wise Providence puts sorrow on the other side of the scales, if the first is to hold such a full measure.

Supplement 55

The Dissertation on Venia Legendi has the following title:

Dissertatio historico-medica de Helleborismo veterum Quam Gratiosi medicorum ordinis auctoritate in auditorio maiori D. XXVI Junii MDCCCXII defendet auctor Samuel Hahnemann Medicinae et chirurgiae Doctor acad. Moguntinae scientiar utilium societies phys. med. Erlang. et societ.

regiae oeconom. quae Lipsiae floret sodalis honorarius Respondente Frederico Hahnemann filio art. lib. Mag. etc. med. bacc.

Lipsiae impressit Carolus Tauchnitz.

English: Historic-medicinal essay on treatment and cure with Hellebore of the Ancients.

Delivered by kind permission of the medical faculty in the large Audience Hall, on June 26th, 1812, defended by the author Samuel Hahnemann, doctor of medicine and surgery, honorary member of the Society of applied sciences at Mayence, of the physical and medical Society of Erlangen, of the Royal economic Society, which flourishes in Leipsic; it will be answered by his son Fredrick Hahnemann, Master of Arts and Bachelor of Medicine [Student who is just about to take his examinations for his Doctor's degree-- R.H.). Leipsic, printed by Karl Tauchnitz.

The essay consisted of 86 pages. After a short introduction Hellebore is described as a remedy in insanity and as an emetic; "helleborosus," one who require much Hellebore is not in his right mind. Then are considered consecutively: the initial use of Hellebore as a medicine; Hellebore as the oldest remedy, especially as a purgative, proved by the testimony of ancient writers. Then follows an investigation into the question, whether Helleborus albus is the same plant as our Veratrum album. Hahnemann answers this in the affirmative, for the healing properties of both are not only similar but identical. (Proof: the testimony of many earlier and recent physicians).

Then are named the districts in Greece where Hellebore grows best, and the characteristics of especially good plants are enumerated. The description of the repeated medicinal use in the majority of cases of chronic diseases is proved with examples of important cases.

After that is shown, when Hellebore was first used and to what extent; further, at what time of the year, against what kinds of diseases, and for what types of people Hellebore was used by the ancients, when according to their ideas it was advantageous and when injurious; the preparation of the patient before using it; the way in which Veratrum album should be employed; what the Ancients mixed with Veratrum as a remedy; what to do for the condition of vomiting which regularly followed its use; the curing of the unfavourable and serious symptoms which arise from the effects of Veratrum. It concludes with some remarks on Helleborus niger.

In the professional criticism this essay met with approval without-as can be well understood-paying too much attention to it. It was not a polemical writing, and therefore had disappointed all parties in their expectations, as much those who had hoped for a new fundamental precept in the homoeopathic sense as also those who had expected further violent attacks on the old medical science. As neither the one nor the other day before them they passed quickly over this profoundly scientific work. Yet the reviewer writes in the "Med. Chir. Ztg.," Supplement 192, page 234:

Although the effects of Veratrum may not be as helpful, as the author believes, there remains yet another merit, that is, the historical compilation of all the methods of treatment with available dates, and in this way the complete historical representation belongs entirely to the author; such a work as the one before us is all the more interesting as similar works are very rare. The earliest traces of the use of Veratrum album can be followed back to 1500 B.C.

And in the "Allgem. med. Annales" of the nineteenth century, 1812, page 1053, another reviewer says that the dissertation is "an interesting contribution to the history of medical science, diligently collected and estimated with a critical spirit." A third one calls it (in Augustin, Wissensch. Ubersetz. der ges. med-chir. Literature, 1812, page 337), "a very thorough essay."

That must hold good, even to-day, when we consider the authors and sources of knowledge that Hahnemann mentions in his writing. From Hippocrates, the famous Aesculapius of antiquity (460-377 B.C.) the chain goes uninterruptedly on to Antyllus (Greek surgeon at the end of the third or beginning of the fourth century, handed down by Oribasius), then to Aretaeus (Greek physician of Kappadocia, at the end of the first, or early in the second century, who is considered the best observer of diseases after Hippocrates), on again to Claudius Galenus, the most renowned physician of antiquity after Hippocrates (died 31 A.D.), and then passing over to the Oriental Mesue, of whom Hahnemann, himself, says in an annotation, he--who lived under the reign of the Caliph Harun Af-Raschid, about the year 800-was a man of such importance that he has been child the Evangelist of the physicians. At his side is put Avicenna Ibn Sina, born 980, near Buchara, died 1037, at Hamadan, who is considered the greatest Oriental medical man. And so the line continues on to Theophrastus Paracelsus (born 1493, died 1541) down to the recognised great ones of the profession such as Haller and others. Then naturalists and historians are included, thus Herodotus (500 B.C.), Ktesias (400 B.C.), Plinius (79 A.D.), Pausanias (160 A.D.); an extensive and collective list of scientists of all times and all nations!

Supplement 56

LETTER ON THE SUBJECT OF HAHNEMANN'S ADDRESS, FOR ACQUIRING THE RIGHT OF A LECTURESHIP.

Dr. Huck wrote to a friend (Albrecht, Hahnemann's Life and Work, page 30):

Lutzen, August 9th, 1812.

Dear Friend,

Though I do not usually like to talk to anyone about one of the greatest thinkers of all the centuries, yet I gladly write to you about the man who, by evident proofs of his great ability, has in a short time wholly won over to himself the unprejudiced portion of the medical as well as the other scientists of Leipsic. To hear Hahnemann, the keenest and boldest investigator of nature, deliver a masterpiece of his intellect and industry, was to me a truly beatific enjoyment. I drove back home to my own town as if in a dream, and was desolate as I was obliged to acknowledged to myself, "You are not worthy to lose the latchets of his shoes." He will deliver private lectures at Michaelmas. I shall be a student next year again, and if exceptional circumstances do not prevent it, will see what I can derive from this wonderful source. If Hahnemann would stoop to act contrary to his noble character and play the hypocrite, like so many other seemingly great men, even the most renowned physicians of Leipsic would be obliged to lower their pretentions. The strongest of his opponents were so courteous as to acknowledge that they were wholly of his opinion, medically speaking, and they thought that if anyone wished to say anything he would be obliged to discuss the matter philologically. He covered himself with renowned he remained victor.

Had it not been a very unsuitable time to look for him on that day, I would have gone to him, and should have voluntarily and unconditionally betaken myself to his banner.

SAMUEL HAHNEMANN

Supplement 57

HAHNEMANN IN THE LECTURE ROOM.

Dr. Franz Hartmann, a pupil and friend of Hahnemann during his sojourn in Leipsic, tells us about Hahnemann's lectures at Leipsic University ("Allg. hom. Ztg." 1844, Vol. 26, page 182):

I cannot hide that Hahnemann presented, from his arrival to his departure from the lecture room, such a peculiar appearance, that would have taken men of his own type of mind and age, to look seriously into his eyes; but for the fact that young minds and particularly cheery students, are easily stimulated to laughter at the slightest provocation, and easily find reasons and look for them, it would have been impossible to demand a serious demeanour.

However imposing and commanding respect, Hahnemann's external appearance was in his simple study, with his upright carriage, his firm step, his plain way of dressing, just as much was his appearance grotesque for this one hour: even he seemed to enjoy himself, and was trying to draw attention in a genial way. Think of the tension of the audience before his arrival, who as yet did not know the enthusiastic reformer, or, perhaps were rubbing their hands in joyous anticipation of the volcanic eruptions-and you will tender forgiveness for the smile, when you hear the outer door open and hear his step in the adjacent room, where he remains standing at the door, clears his throat, and then turns the key round twice in the lock; the door which is usually locked is seen to open, and a man enters of middle height and strong build; the few hairs of the thoughtful head are carefully curled and powdered, inspiring respect for his advanced age, which would have been apparent even if the bald crown and white hair had not been powdered; add to that the beautiful white linen round the neck and on the chest. The black waistcoat and the short black trousers; on the button of the latter was fastened the strap of his shining black top boots, above which appeared the finest white stockings. Think of this figure as after three measured steps he gives an almost imperceptible nod of the head as a sign of greeting, then takes three more steps and having arrived at his chair, in front of which is a little table, he sits down with pathos after removing carefully the shining tails of his coat, opens the book, takes out his watch and puts it on the table before him, then clears his throat, reads the respective paragraph with ordinary voice, but becomes more ecstatic during his explanations, with shining and sparkling eyes, and great redness of the forehead and face--I ask how could it be possible to keep a serious face in front of such a Spanish grandezza which appears in the same way every time; in young years when one is inclined to ridicule everything and not even spare old age

Supplement 58

HAHNEMANN AND HIS PUPILS.

Dr. Fr. Hartmann tells us from his own experience, of the family gatherings at Hahnemann's own house ("Allg. hom. Ztg." 1844, Vol. 26, page 183):

We often had an opportunity of admiring the amicability with which he charmed us all when we made part of his family. There sat the silver-haired old man, with his high arched, thoughtful brow, his bright, piercing eyes, and calm searching countenance, in the midst of us, as among his children, who likewise participated in those evening entertainments. Here he showed plainly that the serious exterior which he exhibited in every day life, belonged only to his deep and constant search after the goal which he had set himself, but was in no respect the mirror of his interior, the bright side of which so readily unfolded itself on suitable occasions in its fairest light, and the mirthful humour, the familiarity and openness, the wit that he displayed were alike engaging.

HAHNEMANN AT LEIPSIC UNIVERSITY

How comfortable the master felt in the circle of his beloved and his friends, among whom he numbered not only his pupils but also the learned of other faculties, who did homage to his learning; how beneficial was the recreation which he then allowed himself after eight o'clock in the evening seated in his arm chair wearing his velvet cap and dressing-gown, with a glass of light Leipsic white beer and his pipe. It was highly interesting at such times to see him become cheerful, as he related the procedure of the older physicians at the sick bed, when with an animated countenance he moved the little cap to and fro upon his head, and puffed out clouds of tobacco smoke, which enveloped him like a fog; when he spoke of his deeply affecting life and related circumstances of it, his pipe often went out, and one of his daughters was then instantly required to light it again. He liked to converse especially on objects of the natural sciences or on conditions of foreign countries and their inhabitants, and he appeared displeased when in these hours his advice was sought in cases of disease. He was then either laconic, or called out to the patients in a friendly way "tomorrow on this subject," not in order to put the matter aside, but because he was too tired to speak on serious subjects, for often he would refer to the question raised, during his consulting hours on the following day, and stood by with his kind advice. He liked to see people express their opinion openly, even if they contradicted him, and occasionally he would surrender his opinion to that of his opponent.

And after describing the simple life of Hahnemann's family, to which we shall refer again, Dr. Hartmann continues:

Perhaps the suppers which were given once or twice a year by Hahnemann to his pupils formed a suitable means of bringing a little change into this monotonous way of living, but he never invited any but those who distinguished themselves through diligence, intelligence and strict morality. During these supper parties things were not altogether homoeopathic, for although I can vouch for a perfect simplicity of the food served, yet instead of white beer, a good wine was provided, of which, however, out of deference to the Master only a moderate amount was consumed. At these entertainments Hahnemann, on the one side and his wife on the other, separated his family from the guests (five daughters; his son and two married daughters were no longer at home). Joyous humour and wit dominated these gatherings, and the desire to laugh was unending, for as a rule other talented men were invited. Here Hahnemann was the most cheerful man, even entering into the pranks of the others, yet without offending propriety, or making any one present the target of his jokes. When the meal was ended a pipe was smoked, and about 11 o'clock the gathering dispersed.

Supplement 59

HAHNEMANN'S UNION FOR PROVING REMEDIES.

Dr. Franz Hartmann, a member of this Provers' Union (which from the beginning consisted of Stapf, Gross, Hornburg, Franz, Wislicenus, Teuthorn, Herrmann, Ruckert, Langhammer, and Hartmann) tells us of these provings in the "Allg. hom. Ztg." (Vol. 38, No. 19 and 20, year 1850):

I went to Leipsic University at eighteen years of age (1814) and after the first quarter was introduced to Hahnemann's more intimate circle of pupils, by the oldest friend of my childhood, Hornburg. Unlearned as we yet were in medicine, and still more so in the proper method of proving drugs, there was nothing left for him--Hahnemann--but to teach us first, and to instruct us minutely in the course we were to pursue, in every respect; this he did in a few words, yet in the clearest and most perceptible manner, as follows:

The human body in the years when it has attained a development nearly complete, is the least exposed to sickness from transient influence, or from the deprivation of its accustomed food, because the powers of life existing in their integrity over power any injurious effects from such causes before they can make any progress; hence, in the case of young persons, a long preparatory course is not necessary before proving a drug; a resolute determination alone is requisite to avoid everything which may tend to disturb the process. During such a proving he absolutely forbade coffee, tea, wine, brandy and all other heating drinks, as well as spices, such as pepper, ginger also strongly salted foods and acids. He did not forbid the use of the light white and brown Leipsic beer. He cautioned us against close and continued application to study, or reading novels, as well as against many games which exercised not merely the imagination, but which required continued thought, such as hazard, cards, chess, or billiards, by which observation was disturbed and rendered untrustworthy. He was far from considering idleness as necessary, but advised moderate labour only, agreeable conversation, with walking in the open air, temperance in eating and drinking, early rising; for a bed he recommended a mattress with light covering.

The medicines which were to be proved he gave us himself; the vegetables in the form of essence or tincture-the others in the first or second trituration . He never concealed from us the names of the drugs which were to be proved, and his wish that we should in the future prepare all the remedies whose effects we had while students conscientiously tried, fully convinced us that in this respect he had never deceived us. Since he for the most part had previously proved the drugs upon himself and his family, he was sufficiently acquainted with their strength and properties to prescribe for each prover according to his individuality, the number of drops or grains with which he might commence, without experiencing any injurious effects. The dose to be taken was mixed with a great quantity of water, that it might come in contact with a greater surface than would be possible with an undiluted drug; it was taken early in the morning, fasting, and nothing was eaten for an hour. If no effect was experienced in three or four hours, a few more drops were to be taken; the dose might even be doubled, and the reckoning of time was to begin from the last dose; the same was the case where the drug was to be taken for the third time. If, upon the third repetition, no change was remarked, Hahnemann concluded that the organism was not susceptible to this agent, and did not require the prover to make any further experiments with it, but after several days gave him another drug to prove. In order to note down every symptom which presented itself, he required each one to carry a tablet and lead pencil with him, which had this advantage, that we could describe with precision the sensation (pain) which we had experienced at the time, while this precision might be lost if these sensations were noted down at same subsequent period. Every symptom that presented itself must be given in its connection, even though the most heterogeneous symptoms were thus coupled together; but our directions were still more precise; after every symptoms we must specify in brackets, the time of its occurrence, which time was reckoned from the last dose. It was only when one or two days had passed without the occurrence of any symptoms that Hahnemann supposed the action of the drug to be exhausted, he then allowed the system a time to rest before another proving was undertaken. He never took the symptoms which we gave him for true and faithful, but always reviewed them once with us, to be sure that we had used just the right expressions and signs, and had said neither too much nor too little. At first it often happened that there were errors, but these became fewer with every proving, and finally there were none at all. At least with those who understood the importance of the matter, and who therefore took these provings sufficiently seriously. In this matter I could always pride myself, and can therefore even now rely firmly upon my own symptoms.

It is an art of its own, this proving of medicines, and it is not as easy as it appears, because it requires a particular kind of attention to grasp properly the symptoms which could only be felt faintly, and these are often just the most important, the really characteristic ones, and of much greater significance than those which set in more violently. The former set in as a rule only after small, delicate doses, while the latter owe their onset to the stronger doses. Another thing which I experienced myself, was that, I rarely could count upon the symptoms after a second, or third, stronger dose, if the first had passed without any traces to symptoms; but if after the first dose only faint symptoms made themselves felt, I could rely with certainty that with every hour they would become more prominently developed and more characteristic. More than once I thought of accentuating their clearness by a second more powerful dose, but I deceived myself almost every time and had frequently to experience, to my sorrow, that no more symptoms showed themselves.

Many of Hahnemann's pupils continued later with their proving when in general practice, by which means they remained in touch with the Master.

TWO OF HAHNEMANN'S LETTERS TO DR. STAPF ON THE PROVING OF MEDICINES.

Stapf, physician of Naumberg, was one of the first disciples of Hahnemann.

Leipsic, 3rd September, 1813. (Stapf's Archiv, Vol. 21, Part I, p.156.)

You are right, that the aggravation caused by a medicine most probably indicates, that the prescribed medicine has the power of exciting these symptoms of itself. We must not, however, incorporate such symptoms in the list of the purely positive effect of medicine, at least not in writing. We can only bear them in mind in order to give them due attention, should they occur pure (that is, not having been there previously) on using the same medicine.

When I propose anything for proving, I will take care that it is nothing which will ruin health, and so prepared that it will not affect you too violently; for we are not entitled to do injury to ourselves. I send you along with this some tincture of pure Helleborus niger, which I gathered myself. Each drop contains only one twentieth grain of the root. Any day when you are well, and have no very urgent business, and are not eating any medicinal substances (such as parsley or horse-radish, etc.) with your mid-day meal, take one drop of this to eight ounces of water, and a scruple of alcohol (to prevent its decomposition during the time of using it), shake it briskly, and take one ounce before breakfast; and so every hour and a half, or two hours another ounce, as long as you are not too severely affected by what you take. But should severe symptoms set in, which I am not afraid of, you may take some drops of tincture of Camphor in one ounce of water, or more if necessary, and this will allay the symptoms.

After all the effects of the Hellebore have subsided, I wish you to try the effects of Camphor alone (it is a divine remedy). About two grains dissolved in a scruple of alcohol, and shaken with eight ounces of water, are to be taken four or six times a day, with similar precautions as the other.

In another letter to Dr. Stapf we read:

Leipsic, 17th December, 1816. Stapf's Archiv, Vol. 21, Part I, p.160.

I thank you for the symptoms you sent me, some of them are of importance. Strive more and more to discover the exact expression for the sensations which have arisen, and the changes in your well-being, as well as the conditions under which they appear. My pupils here have an easier task in this respect. Whenever they present me with such a list, I go through the symptoms along with them, and question them right and left, so as to complete from their recollection whatever requires to be more explicit, such as time, conditions under which the changes took place, etc. But you must do all this yourself, go through the already written observations by yourself, in order to discover where there is still a gap to be found, where there is still something to correct. In that respect yours is a more difficult task.

This strictness of mine for the promotion of truth, will show you that your plan, (Stapf had proposed to Hahnemann to issue an appeal to all physicians, and invite them to join in the proving of medicines.) although very well meant, is quite impracticable; they would smile at us and even scoff. Which of our everyday colleagues would undertake such laborious experiments, when he can tap upon his well-filled receipt-book and say:

"Thou art my comfort! never can I be in doubt what to prescribe when I have thee at hand. It may go with my patients as it likes; I am quite safe. These receipts of the learned masters, as long as I prescribe them, no person can find fault with me." It would be in vain to attempt to elevate the views of such people, even in an eternity they could not be elevated to this purer idea. They will never resolve to carry out these careful observations, seeing that the ordinary physician feels quite comfortable with-out observing, but just leisurely imitating others in leaving everything to the old ways, to assumptions and despotism! No, let all such hopes vanish. Such resolutions are not to be thought of such people. And what would the execution be like, if they made an attempt (perhaps out of curiosity) Deceptions, imaginative stuff, or positive falsehoods, with their irregular mode of life, their volatility and their deficiency in the spirit of observation and integrity; may God keep the pure doctrine from such dross.

No, it is only the young whose heads are not deluged to over-flowing with a flood of everyday dogmas, and in whose arteries there runs not yet the stream of medical prejudices; it is only such young and unconstrained natures, who consider truth and philanthropy of some value, that are open to our simple doctrines of medicine; only these will of their own free-will endeavour, as I notice with joy in my pupils, to bring to the light, by their own sacrifice, those endless treasures of medicinal powers, which have been left hidden, or unexplored from the beginning of time by a crazy and self-complacent ignorance; I think some of them have made considerable progress in the practice of observation-so will the good be sown-but only where it finds suitable soil. One word more; no encomiums of me; I dislike them; for I feel myself to be nothing more than an upright man who merely does his duty. Let us express our regard for one another only in simple words and conduct indicating mutual respect.

HOW HAHNEMANN CARRIED OUT HIS PROVINGS OF MEDICINES.

To this enquiry from an unknown D.G., in the "Allgem. Anzeiger der Deutschen," No. 24, of January 25th, 1839, Hahnemann gives the following reply which affords a deeper insight into the manner in which these provings were undertaken, as well as all the details under consideration, together with a description of all his pupils and friends who took part in the provings.

This enquiry in the "Allgem. Anzeiger d. Deutschen" (No. 24, January 25th, 1839) by a to me unknown D.G. would not have come forth if he had appreciated what I have taught ("Organon," fifth edition, 121 to 142) and if he had presupposed (as would be presupposed in my case) that I would not have taught anything of which I had not previously convinced myself through personal experiments. Therefore he cannot possibly have read it.

I gave the medicines prepared by myself for this purpose in higher or lower dynamisations, in larger or smaller doses, as everyone could take without being too exhausted by it. Most of the symptoms as one will see, where the name of the prover is not mentioned, have been observed by me, or by members of my family, to whom I gave the remedy myself. The medicines were usually taken dissolved in a larger or smaller quantity of water, once or twice daily, or less frequently, in order to become acquainted with the effects of the medicines in every respect. The chief thing was, always to see that the provers should be free from erroneous diet and mode of living, as healthy as possible, and keen to explore the high truths which we are expecting to find, with a strong sense of conscientious honestly, without expecting the slightest worldly advantage, not even to hope for the honour of being publicly mentioned as a prover. They were mostly wellknown friends and hearers of my lectures. Each one of them was interrogated daily, or every two or three days, on the symptoms experienced by them, partly in order to enquire if any one of them had previously experienced by them, partly in order to enquire if anyone of them had previously experienced similar sensations (that this might be put in brackets when printing as not altogether due to the medicine), partly that the exact character of his sensations and observations might be compared with the words written down, and perhaps afterwards be able to choose with his consent more definite expressions. All the important secondary considerations of any value were mentioned at the same time together with the symptoms under which they occurred; I drew the attention of each of them, beforehand, to such conditions.

All were persons capable of carrying out observations, and of absolute honesty of purpose, so that I could vouch for them, and I do; each was striving for the holy purpose of seeking these new and indispensable discoveries for the welfare of suffering humanity, giving his time, even sacrificing his health, so as to carry out with true zeal, the best possible work for the good cause. In this way I continue even now to perfect the true art of healing. Those who are not satisfied with the simple carefulness required to reach the desired goal, which is all that is necessary, and those who seem to think unnecessary the pure zeal for holy truth and the strict conscientiousness in these medicinal provings that were not done for the sake of money, let them enquire from the great talker of Carlsruhe (he means, Dr. Griesselich-R.H.) who does not trouble so much about truth and conscientiousness, and zeal for the welfare of humanity, (He conducted his military hospital unashamed on allopathic lines. and who still endeavours to keep the world, which has been deceived for thousands of years, in these deceptions by writing in No. 10 of the eighth vol. of the Allgem. hom. Zeit., 1836, of more perfect new medical provings, that his wisdom is dreaming about, for the price of twelve ducats, and who appoints the socalled judges who are to award the prize for the best essay. Among whom he is included, who also shows his inexperience in homoeopathy by asserting that: "Hahnemann's Causticum, does not exist" (is nothing). Why This so important, so extremely powerful, healing and indispensable medicinal substance he does not even know it!)

All that is to be quoted in it, is such voluminous scribble and so unworthy of notice, that a big pamphlet is to be expected from every single remedy. Every outsider, every unknown quisquis sit, can contribute, and that which can only be discovered with difficulty by close and careful intercourse with the provers, is not mentioned. That is, (1) if the prover is capable of carrying out accurate observations upon himself, or if he follows the right diet, and observes the correct conduct for body and soul, and is capable of putting before us in the most adequate words and sentences, what he has observed. (2) If he is so thoroughly imbued and animated by pure and unselfish desire, as to be willing to sacrifice his time and even jeopardise his health for the acknowledgment of truth.

Of this the judge who has to allot the prize has already been able to convince himself, after reading the scribble of the unknown Quidem, and declare himself satisfied, while he can do nothing else but crown the most voluminous and drawn out essay of the unknown, of whom he can assume rightly, that he must be in great need of money, if he is willing to write so much for twelve ducats! It is impossible for the judge to elicit more from the scribble, and he cannot possibly be so impudent as to presume that this scribble be pure truth; he cannot find out from it, if it (in the best of cases) is not at least partly incorrect, if the symptoms recorded are not altogether false, as a few years ago Fickel (to whom had been handed over by his colleagues in Leipsic, the post of physician to the homoeopathic hospital) invented all the printed symptoms, in his so-called proving of the chemical preparation, Osmium, which he had never seen, for the sake of snapping up a bookseller's fee.

How can anyone expect that by offering miserable money prizes to unknown contributors, for the exploration of unknown experiences and experiments, which can only be obtained by honest self-scratching zeal for the welfare of suffering humanity, it could be anything more than mystifications and untruths-this the all-wise talker of Carlsruhe did not see in his conceit, and thus he deceives the world.

Fickel's colleagues in Leipsic imitate him, honouring his wisdom as non plus ultra, and let the homoeopathic hospital disintegrate in order to obtain from the proceeds of the small local money similar prizes for such imaginative self-provings.

Dear humanity, who art in need of pure truth for the healing art, be no longer deceived.

SAMUEL HAHNEMANN.

Paris, 5th May, 1838.

Supplement 60

HOMOEOPATHY WITHOUT PROTECTION.

Hahnemann writes to Stapf: (Stapf's Archiv, Vol. 21, Part 2, p. 128.)

That you will find a great man, who will come over to our side is, in the nature of things, impossible. If he be already a man of celebrity as you represent him, he can have become so only by means of the gross empirical art, which he contrived to support, after some new fashion, by compiling in manuals the thousand times ruminated trash of common medicine, or by hatching some in-elaborate unintelligible, fine-spun system, or by processes and fooleries of the ordinary sort, which he carried further than his colleagues, and raised himself above them only by telling greater and more audacious falsehoods than they. Such an one has long ago decided on the part he must play; he can worship only the false and sophistical system which raised him to his place of honour. Never would he be able to recognise from the wilderness of his multifarious knowledge the dignity of simple, humbling truth; and he would take care to consider them as little as ever he could, should some rays of it tumble upon him, because they would expose the falsehood of all his former knowledge, by which he has become so great, and would leave nothing sound or entire about him, and destroy himself in his knowledge. He would first have to tread underfoot all his mock-consequence before he could even begin to be our pupil; and where would then be the great man, who could have raised us by his high position, when his previous infallibility falls in the dust, and he has to extinguish completely the light of that wisdom to which he owed his exalted station, and learn the new truth, before he could become a worthy pupil of ours How could he become our protector without first receiving the truth we teach, that is, without having first entered our school And then must be thrown away all that rendered him great in the eyes of the world; and even to perform a moderate service in our cause he would need our protection, not we his.

Our science requires no political levers, no worldly decorations. At present it grows with slow progress amid the abundance of weeds which luxuriate about it; it grows unobserved, from an unlikely acorn into a little plant; soon may its head be seen overtopping the tall weeds. Only wait-it is striking deep its roots in the earth; it is strengthening itself unperceived, but all the more certainly in its own time it will increase, till it becomes an oak of God, whose arms unmoved by the wildest storm, stretch in all directions, that the suffering children of men may be revived under its beneficient shadow.

Kind regards from my family and myself.

SAMUEL HAHNEMANN. Leipsic, 19th September, 1815.

Supplement 61

WORKS AND ESSAYS WRITTEN BY HAHNEMANN DURING HIS SOJOURN IN LEIPSIC.

1811-1821. Materia Medica Pura. Dresden, Arnold.

Part I, 1811, 248 pp.; 2nd amplif. edit., 1823; 3rd amplif. edit., 1830.

Part 2, 1816, 396 pp.; 2nd amplif. edit., 1824; 3rd amplif. edit., 1833.

Part 3, 1816, 288 pp.; 2nd amplif. edit., 1825.

Part 4, 1818, 284 pp.; 2nd amplif. edit., 1825.

Part 5, 1819, 306 pp.; 2nd amplif. edit., 1826.

Part 6, 1821, 255 pp.; 2nd amplif. edit., 1826.

1812. His Dissertation on Helleborismus Veterum. (Lesser Writings).

1813. Spirit of the New Medical Doctrine, "Allg. Anz. d. Deutschen," March, pp. 626 (later completed and printed in front of Part 2 of M.M.P.).

1814. Method of Treatment for the Now Prevailing Nerve and Hospital Fever ("Allg. Anz. der Deutschen," No. 6). (Lesser Writings).

1816. On Venereal Diseases and its Ordinary Improper Treatment. (Ibid., No. 211). (Lesser Writings).

1816. On the Treatment of Burns. (Ibid., No. 156 and 204). (Lesser Writings).

1819. On Uncharitableness towards Suicides. (Ibid., No. 144). (Lesser Writings).

1820. On the Preparation and Dispensing of Medicines by Homoeopathic Physicians themselves. Reply to an accusation of the Leipsic Apothecaries. (Stapf, Lesser Writings).

1821. Medical Advice on Purpura Miliaris. "Allg. Anz. d. Deutschen," No. 26. (Lesser Writings).

The separate volumes of the Materia Medica Pura frequently contain very particular and detailed Symptom-Index of the individual medicines.

These were always preceded by instructions on the preparation of medicines for Homoeopathic use, together with an historical account on the use of the respective medicine, and the chief disease symptoms in which this medicine is to be used. Special mention is made of the co-operation of his pupils in establishing the effect of medicines.

Of the third edition of the Materia Medica Pura, only the two first volumes appeared; the four others did not appear. C. Hering writes on this in "North. Amer. Jour. of Hom." (Vol. 22, p. 102):

We have not received the last four volumes of the third edition of Materia Medica Pura, because the "anti-Hahnemannians" have by their shouting and boasting brought such disrepute on this work that the Materia Medica as well as the greater part of the second edition of Chronic Diseases, 1835-1839, became void.

A Latin translation under the title "Materia Medical Pura," was made by Dr. Stapf, Dr. Wilh. Gross, and Ernst Georg von Brunnow (but only the first two volumes appeared, Leipsic, 1826- 1828, by Arnold).

The Materia Medica Pura was translated into Italian by Dr. Romani (Naples) and published 1825-1828. A second Italian translation by Dr. Dadea, appeared in 1873 at Turin. Dr. Bigel of Warschau made a French translation in 1828. A second French translation was published by Dr. Jourdan in Paris, 1834, and in the year 1877, followed a third translation by Dr. Leon Simon. Dr. Hempel made (1846) an English translation which was published by Radde, in New York. In the year 1880. Dr. Dudgeon published, in London, by the Homoeopathic Publishing Co., an English translation in two volumes.

A REMONSTRANCE

Hahnemann wrote, preceding the second amplified edition of "Materia Medica Pura" (Vol. 4, 1825), "A Remonstrance." In it he attacks strongly the "existing humdrum routine of treatment," the "pathology," the artificially built up, invented phantom diseases, the generally manufactured disease forms, for which, specialised methods of treatment, even with pocket-books of prescriptions, were devised by therapeutics. If the physician found that the illness of a patient did not correspond sufficiently with one of the pathological forms of disease, so that he was unable to give it a name, he was then free according to his books, to attribute the evil to a much deeper and hidden origin, and then (on this fabrication) arrange a treatment (of which Hahnemann gives several instances-R.H.). "Is perhaps," asks Hahnemann, "after 2,300 years duration, of this criminal mode of proceeding, not even yet to dawn the day of release for suffering humanity Are the requests of patients to listen to their tale of sufferings, to vanish into empty air, unheeded by their brethren, without attracting the attention of any human heart, in a practical way "

Thus Hahnemann demands here that the strikingly different accounts which every patient has to give of his complaints, shall be listened to, because they signify his specific disease. "It would be, therefore, the duty of the physician to distinguish the subtle differentiations of every individual case"-that is to specialise and individualise in each case, instead of treating groups of diseases.

Then he attacks large doses of medicine:

These harmful, often very harmful substances (which are only useful in the appropriate case) the specific effects of which are unknown, are blindly seized upon, or else in accordance with the orders of that book of lies, called-that is misnamed-Materia Medica, are mixed together (unless the prescription is copied as it stands, from the prescription-book) although their own specific action is unknown, as if they were taken from the wheel of fortune, or rather misfortune, and then the already suffering patient is tortured still more with this barbaric hotch-potch of a vile smell and taste.

The honest physician will proceed differently. He "will watch the patient carefully with all his faculties, will have made the patient tell him directly all his pains and attacks, and have them completed by the relatives, and note them down in writing, without adding or subtracting anything." Then he has a true knowledge of the disease, of what has to be removed and cured. But before a physician begins to practise, he must have acquainted himself well "with the changes in health which are brought about in man by individual medicines, so that he may choose that medicine which would bring about such changes in the particular case of illness." This leads us to the proving of medicines on healthy subjects, and the rejection of mixed remedies.

In a second foreword with the title "The Medical Observer," which has explicitly been called only a "fragment," Hahnemann demands from the scientific healer the capacity and practice, "to perceive accurately and clearly the disease conditions, either of natural diseases, or those brought about artificially by the proving of medicines, and to note them down in suitable terms." This requires of the physician that he, so to speak, holds on to the object with all his intellectual grasp, so that nothing may remain unnoticed which is actually there and belongs to the case. The inventive imagination, the deceiving wit, every kind of supposition, all subtle reasoning, strained interpretations, and desire to explain, must all retreat. Then Hahnemann continues:

The capacity for accurate observation, is perhaps never quite hereditary; it must be acquired for the greater part by practice, by refining and correcting sense-impressions, that means, perfecting by strict criticism our quickly formed opinions of external objects, and the cool and tranquil firmness of our judgment must remain under the constant supervision of mistrust in our power of comprehension. The great importance of this, our object, must be to direct body and soul on these observations, and a much exercised patience, upheld by strong will-power, must fortify us in this respect until the completion of our observations.

Familiarity with the best writings of the Ancients, the Greeks and the Romans, the art of drawing, and also mathematics assists the medical observer. Then it continues:

The best opportunity for exercising our sense of observation and to perfect it, is by proving medicines ourselves. After avoiding all extraneous medicinal influences, and all disturbing mind impressions, the prover must remain at attention for this important business from the time he takes the medicine, alert to all changes of sensation, so that with increasing feeling and open mind he may record them and note down truthfully.

Through the continued tracing of the changes which are occurring in himself, the observer acquires the power to perceive all, even the most complex sensations which he experiences when proving the medicine, and also the most minute changes in his condition, and to write down in an adequate and exhaustive way the conception which has become clear to him.

Only here it is possible for the beginner to observe undisturbed, clearly and correctly, as he knows that he will not deceive himself, that no one is telling him an untruth, and that he feels, sees, and notices for himself what is happening to him and in him. Thus he forms a practice of observing accurately where others are concerned.

The existing symptomatology of the common medical science will strike the man, who makes such requests as of a superficial nature. A single word, or a general expression for the designation of the frequently so very complicated disease sensations and symptoms (such as perspiration, heat, fever, headache, sore-throat, cough, stomach-ache, want of appetite, etc.) is altogether insufficient, considering the innumerable and varied sufferings of patients. The conscientious physician would have to be infinitely more conscientious in distinguishing that which has to be perceived, the language is hardly sufficient to express is suitable words the many divergences of the symptoms in patients. "This is so true," concludes Hahnemann, "that only the most careful observer can become a true scientific healer."

TABULAR SUMMARY OF

The remedies, and number of symptoms in the provings recorded in the Materia Medica Pura.

2

3

4

NOS. OF SYMPTOMS WHICH HAVE BEEN BORROWED FROM OTHER WRITERS.

5

ON THE EFFECTS OF ARSENIC ON THE DEAD BODY.

Baron von Gersdorff wrote to his friend Hahnemann.

Eisenach, June, 1835.

A former pupil of Dr. Giuseppe Mauro, in Naples, Dr. Guiseppe Tranchina, prosecutor of Anatomy in Palermo, a man of about thirty years of age, with whom I became personally acquainted, in the summer of 1832, and who is very distinguished and capable in his own line, especially in the science of injecting, and in the manufacture of all kinds of anatomical preparations, had discovered a method of preserving the human body, in all its internal and external parts, for a long time, perhaps from four to seven years, which would perfect it from corruption, so well that all its members would remain in a supple condition, and even when the bodies had lost this, to restore it again as in life. The pallor of the corpse, with possible signs of decay, would disappear and give place to a life-like tint, and the hair and all the small nerves would retain their firmness and toughness, so that they could not easily be torn or broken; even when the body was dissected a long time after the preparation, the bad odour was absent, and apart from the absence of warmth the body had an appearance resembling life. This discovery, so important to anatomy and pathology, as well as to many who find pleasure in preserving near them their deceased loved ones, for a long time, so that they might become accustomed to their loss by degrees, Tranchina owes, apart from his sagacity and skill, to Homoeopathy, that is to your Materia Medica, dear friend. He was reading the last symptom on Arsenic: "The body was still fresh and intact after sixteen days," when he thought of a way of treating bodies with a solution of arsenic, so that it could be brought into intimate contact with even the smallest internal and external parts of the corpse. As he is particularly skilled in injecting, he succeeded after many attempts so perfectly, that the above result was obtained. He dissolves one pound of arsenic, sometimes a little more, in twenty-four pounds of spirits of wine, or which is just as good, in the same quantity of water, to this he adds one ounce and a half of red lead or cinnabar, in order to give to the mixture a red colour, and he injects this through an opening in the left carotid (main artery of the neck). In the beginning he found it difficult to overcome the valves of the heart; but later he succeeded, and injected in this way the whole body, even to the finest vessels, with the arsenical fluid. If he thinks that the intestine is in a bad condition, he makes an opening in the abdomen and introduces the arsenic through the canula that is used to draw off the fluid in dropsy (instrument for paracentesis); then both openings are sewn up, and the corpse can be kept anywhere, even exposed to the air, without any fear of decomposition taking place. In the beginning his discovery met with very little credit and approval; he attracted only jealousy and hatred from the physicians of Palermo, and was unable to obtain a higher degree as physician for the disclosure of his secret. Later, quite a sensation was caused, when it became known that the body of a prince, so prepared by him, was still intact at the end of three months; this fact induced the Pope to have his friend, Cardinal Zuola, who died in Palermo this winter, preserved so that he might bring him to Rome. On account of the unfavourable weather it was sixtysix days before the body travelled to Rome, accompanied by Tranchina, and everybody in Palermo was able to see it. Tranchina received there from the Mayor, a reward of 400 ducats, also much honour and was made a knight by the Pope, who saw that his friend's body was so unchanged and as if still alive. His Holiness kept the body near him for three months; he gave Tranchina four gold medals, and 100 scudi. In Naples Tranchina had to undergo some public tests, which gave full satisfaction. The translation of Menach's letter of May 14th of this year, which will shortly appear in the "Anzeiger," to which I sent it to-day, will describe these in detail. Tranchina received-as England wanted him, and he would have been very wise to have accepted-from the King 3,000 ducats, the Order of Francis I, and the position of second physician in the Military Hospital of Naples, with the exclusive right for ten years, but with the condition that he must disclose his secret and mode of procedure to the Medical Faculty. This happened on April 11th of this year, and he has prepared two corpses, one with spirit and one with water for the inspection of the physicians; these bodies have been placed in a closed and sealed room which will only be opened after forty days. The prosecutors of the German University will probably try to imitate this when they hear of it, but only the most skilful will succeed perfectly.

Your true friend and godfather,

A. FREIH. V. GERSDORFF, Geh. Reg. Rat.

METHOD OF CURING THE NOW PREVAILING NERVE AND HOSPITAL FEVERS.

Dr. Stapf gives us this essay in the "Lesser Writings" of S. Hahnemann, with the following annotation:

After the return of the French troops from Russia in 1812, and the many hardships connected with war, a peculiar war epidemic spread all over Germany, a contagious typhus of a strange kind, for which the chief specific remedies seemed in many cases to be Nux vomica and Pulsatilla. After the battle of Leipsic in the autumn of 1813, a typhus developed which was quite different from the other but not less devastating, to fight this, various methods of treatment were suggested and were carried out with more or less success. No striking results crowned any of these methods. Hahnemann made known in the above essay a method of treatment for this peculiar kind of typhus, entirely different from all the other methods but capable of really curing it, after he had obtained decidedly happy results in his own practice. He treated 180 cases of typhus in Leipsic and only one old patient died; a stroke of luck of which very few physicians could boast. How little honour and recognition was aroused for his method of treatment proved useless, is a well known fact which does not bring much honour to certain people.

The publisher ("Allg. Anz. der Deutschen," F.G. Becker, No. 6. year 1814).

ON THE CONTENTS OF THE WRITING

We have only to say briefly:

After Hahnemann had explained how useless all the existing remedies were for this disease, he shows the symptoms of the new fever in two main stages, and recommends for the first stage, Bryonia alba and Rhus tox., for the second Hyoscyamus niger. If in certain cases a third stage appears of partial paralysis of the mental faculties, sweet spirit of nitre,-one drop in an ounce of water-a teaspoonful to be given at a time.

"On the Treatment of Venereal Disease," contains nothing new for homoeopaths according to Hartmann's statement. Naturally he objects energetically against the local dispersion of the evil and the too drastic cures by mercury.

"On the Treatment of Burns,"- two essays in the "Allgem. Anz. der Deutschen," No. 156 and 204 of 1816.-These essays were the outcome of Prof. Dzondis' praise of the "only sure remedy" for burns, which consisted of cold water. Hahnemann recommends instead warm spirits of wine (see literary contest with Dr. Dzondi, Chapter 11).

"ON UNCHARITABLENESS TOWARDS SUICIDES"

Is a small essay based on the principle, "a disease condition almost always underlies suicide," which can frequently be an epidemic, and attack more often than not "honest and moral people instead of bad scoundrels." This disease of the mind not infrequently follows a bodily ailment which has been overlooked by the physician and the relatives, and Hahnemann advises us to fight it with a "small dose (one billion times diluted) of gold dust," Aurum metallicum, which can be mixed with the beverage of the patient.

Materia Medica Pura, and the 2nd Edition of the "Organon."

Dear Mr. Arnold,

Please send by the next post the 25 r. (Probably the remuneration for one of the six parts of "Materia Medica," published by Arnold, 1811-1821.) and kindly state in writing the conditions regarding the second edition of the "Organon" ( The second much improved edition of the "Organon," published by Arnold, 1819.) which we discussed together, so that I may begin at once with the work which will require much time.

I am surprised that you do not think of my Materia Medica when you advertise your publications in the public papers. One of my correspondents has complained to me about it.

What are you doing, how are you Is life still interesting

Your faithful friend,

DR. SAM. HAHNEMANN.

L. (Leipsic), 27th June, 1817. To Mr. Ch. Arnold, Publisher in Dresden.

What is in this library

These titles sit beside the repertory: Allen’s Keynotes, Anshutz on the twelve tissue remedies, Boericke’s materia medica, Clarke’s Dictionary, Hering, Jones, Kent’s lectures, Nash, and Boger’s Synoptic Key. Philosophy includes Hahnemann’s Organon (5th and 6th), Kent, Close, Burnett, Haehl, Gibson Miller, Royal, J. H. Allen, and Anshutz. Clinical, therapeutics, regional works, and short remedy pictures follow the same shelf.

Chapter text is on this shelf for study: open a title, then a heading. When a medicine appears in more than one materia medica, switch authors on the chapter to compare how each describes it. For educational use by students and qualified practitioners. Not medical advice.

Back to Tools or the repertory.